Got my first 4 book graded

It was kind of a disappointment since I got only 1 9.8 Saga #12. My #2 came back as a 9.2 #7 Ghost Variant made a 9.4 and my #18 was a 9.6 It seemed like they just gave me one of each grade. Not sure what is wrong with them...though I imagine there is a nick in the lower left corner...The #2 I read so I can see that not being perfect but the others went right from the shelf to a bag and board and I saw nothing. I guess I must get a lope and start scrutinizing the books harder or send in 50 and only get the 9.8 cased.

Edited as I am not sure how to reply yet...First off I'd love to have any Walking Dead #1 but I do feel your pain. As for my experience so far, it is still positive even though I didn't get all 10's or 9.8s. The books still display nice and that was want I wanted to do anyway. Me and the wife love this comic (and the New 52 Aquaman) and getting them graded is cheaper then framing to hang on the wall. I will try and upgrade them as suggested. As of the last Saga release I have 50 ungraded books that all look great to me. I might just send them all in and ask for only the 9.8's or better to be cased. I understand from reading the submissions that is acceptable...I also read in the FAQ that if I send in 50 and only 6 grade that I will be charged a review fee (I totally understand it) just wondering what the review fee might be. Since I am only batting .250 at the moment, I'd think I'd be lucky to get 10 9.8's out of that 50 so I might be stuck paying it....Does anyone know? Thanks for all the feedback!

To see old comments for this Journal entry, click here. New comments can be added below.