Graham Ingels is my favorite horror cover artist, but he didn't make it past Everett (who is probably my second favorite).
-
I'm a Schomburg fan mainly because of his early covers for Timely. I like some of his later Timely covers, but they were a little too noisy and a little too cartoonish. Many of the Marvel Mysteries start to look the same after a while. Schomburg's non-airbrushed Better/Nedor covers were very bland; I assume that they were just potboilers that he did quickly for extra money. His airbrushed covers are growing on me.
-
L. B. Cole produced some of my favorite covers of the Golden Age, but many of his covers are lackluster, and he didn't seem to be very good at drawing human faces.
-
I didn't have a chance to vote before the contest was hacked. It would have been a very close call, but I suppose I would have had to vote for Schomburg on the strength of his early Timely covers.