Stats wise Mantle is not even in the top 10. Hank Aaron is way beyond Mantle as are a bunch of other players like Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker (over 3600 hits and hit well over .300), Pete Rose, Derek Jeter, Honus Wagner and so on. Mantle hit 536 HR and did not even get close to 3000 hits and his career average is below .300. At best the guy is somewhere in the top 50 players of all-time.....and I say at best. He is no Babe Ruth that is for sure!!
His cards are way overvalued compared to some other players. I mean give me a break Hank Aaron had 755 HR and almost 3800 hits and averaged over .300 the guy was a machine. Racism played a lot into Mantle been seen as a king but the truth are in his stats. Even Albert Pujols has better stats than Mantle. Pujols will get to 3000 hits and has more than 600 HR. Yes Mantle won championships but that is a team effort.