• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

O Doyle Rules

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    312

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About O Doyle Rules

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1.    Kramerica reacted to a post in a topic: chart of FMV from past years
  2. O Doyle Rules
    I know I have personally provided the proper documentation (proof) where I have purchased CGC comics from online dealers and also where I have made private deals with with CGC members on the WTB forum. GPA analysis will accept it if buyers can properly document their purchase. At least this is my experience.
  3.    Malacoda reacted to a post in a topic: Oddly Similar Comic Covers
  4.    sledgehammer reacted to a post in a topic: CGC Files Lawsuit Against Employees
  5.    onlyweaknesskryptonite reacted to a post in a topic: CGC Files Lawsuit Against Employees
  6.    PetuniaGrimm reacted to a post in a topic: CGC Files Lawsuit Against Employees
  7. O Doyle Rules
    CGC "lost" my books! Sorry felt the need to get this right. Your quotation marks were placed incorrectly.
  8. O Doyle Rules started following RATE YOUR GA BOOKS ON COVER APPEAL ALONE. Forget grading criteria. , Hero Restoration, Anyone know the latest? and ASM #252 CGC 9.8 Record Sale - something fishy going on? - Holder Tampering Incident confirmed by CGC
  9.    Raze reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  10.    Raze reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  11.    alexgross.com reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  12.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  13.    Flanders82 reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  14.    Cushing Fan reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  15. O Doyle Rules
    This is the most egregious example of Woozy's image ruining a fantastic cover. What could the artist been thinking? An amazing work of art absolutely destroyed by Woozy's cartoonish image.
  16.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  17. O Doyle Rules
    No one hates puppies!
  18.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  19. O Doyle Rules
    Wow! I would have to definitely place him in the top 5.
  20.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  21. O Doyle Rules
    However, had it not been for Batman & Robin, we would have never seen this Duo!
  22.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  23.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  24.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  25. O Doyle Rules
    The problem was is they replaced the Human Torch with the wrong Herbie. Had it been Herbie, the Fat Fury that would have been beautiful! Fantastic Four & Fat Fury! Perfect!
  26. O Doyle Rules
    Just like in the real world, life is also not fair in the super hero world. Spider-Man gets to save Mary Jane & Gwen all the time while Plastic Man had to keep bailing out Woozy's fat butt.
  27. O Doyle Rules
    I would guess that just as many would argue that Robin is also the best sidekick of all time which would disqualify him as being the worst of all time. No one is going to argue that Woozy is the best sidekick of all time. Woozy is the worst of the worst!
  28.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Worst Sidekick of all time
  29. O Doyle Rules
    I just purchased Plastic Man #49 and was getting ready to post it in the This Week in my Collection thread when I ran across the Most Unpopular Super Hero thread in the Golden Age forum. That inspired me to start this thread. My nomination has to be Plastic Man's sidekick, Woozy Winks. His image has runied so many great Plastic Man covers! I was able to ignore it enough on this particular cover to still make the purchase. If you replace his image with a hot chick laying on the mad scientist's table this comic instantly turns into a comic that sells for way, way more. Am I right? Please post your candidate for the title of Worst Sidekick. Good luck beating Woozy!
  30. O Doyle Rules
    I was getting ready to post my CGC copy of this issue and make the same point! For this cover alone, I would not place the Green Lama in the lame super hero category. Definitely an amazing Mac Raboy cover!
  31.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: Most unpopular Golden Age superhero
  32.    O Doyle Rules reacted to a post in a topic: This week in your collection?
  33. O Doyle Rules
    OK, in full disclosure this is actually over the last couple of weeks:
  34. O Doyle Rules
    No it does not. It is just the white area above the panels at the top of the page.
  35. O Doyle Rules
    Yea, you're right it could likely be a qualfied grade. If they give it an universal label does it automatically make it a .05 or could it grade higher? It is a golden age comic.
  36. O Doyle Rules
    Not sure the reasoning behind why someone would have done this to the book. The last page was clipped across the top at the ink line. The only thing I can surmise is the owner wanted the title of the book to appear on the inside when it was open? - See pictures. Anyway my real question is will CGC either consider this restoration or deem it to be incomplete and recieve a lower grade? Clearly this was not the usually trim job in an attempt to improve the appearance of the book. Your thoughts are greatly appreciated. Thanks to all who respond!