• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

doomwhistle

Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    56

  • Joined

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1.    scburdet reacted to a post in a topic: Grade is in! PGM New Mutants #98
  2.    Lninefingers reacted to a post in a topic: Grade is in! PGM New Mutants #98
  3. doomwhistle
    Beautiful copy! I am thinking 9.2 to maybe a hard 9.4. It does have some bends and a ticks. Nonetheless, it presents very well. Also, the black color is nice and pronounced!
  4. doomwhistle started following PGM Star Wars 42 and Grade is in! PGM New Mutants #98
  5. doomwhistle
    Hey all! Grade is in! The book was graded as a 9.4 without grader notes. Thanks again for all your thoughts!
  6.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: Grade is in! PGM New Mutants #98
  7.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: Grade is in! PGM New Mutants #98
  8.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: Grade is in! PGM New Mutants #98
  9.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: Grade is in! PGM New Mutants #98
  10. doomwhistle
    I have examined the smudge to the best of my abilities. I even took a magnifying glass to it. It does appear to be part of the printing process, but I am unsure what CGC would say.
  11.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: Grade is in! PGM New Mutants #98
  12. doomwhistle
    Hi gang - picked up this NM 98 for a really good price. I know it has a few flaws and was wondering what you might think. Specifically, there is a printer error in the comic code upper left-hand corner. It appears to be a factory ink smear. Also, there is a dent in the back that I feel could be pressed out. I plan to clean and press the book if it is worth it. Thoughts on the grade? Thanks!
  13.    Sneakerhead76 reacted to a post in a topic: PGM Star Wars 42
  14.    Mars76 reacted to a post in a topic: PGM Star Wars 42
  15.    grendelbo reacted to a post in a topic: PGM Star Wars 42
  16.    scburdet reacted to a post in a topic: PGM - New Mutants #87
  17.    scburdet reacted to a post in a topic: PGM Star Wars 42
  18. doomwhistle
    Grade is in! CGC gave it an 8.5 after C/P. Personally, I felt it should be above a 9.0 but I guess it is what it is. Thanks for all your opinions!
  19. doomwhistle
    Hi gang - Grade is in from CGC. It got a 9.4 after a clean and press. Thanks for all the opinions!
  20. doomwhistle started following Hey buddy, can you spare a grade?
  21.    Mars76 reacted to a post in a topic: PGM - Hulk 140
  22.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: PGM - Hulk 140
  23.    grendelbo reacted to a post in a topic: PGM - Hulk 140
  24. doomwhistle
    I was hoping for a 9.6. But, some feedback appears to lead me to think it might not be possible. To crack and resend for a 9.4 feels like a waste of cash.
  25. doomwhistle
    Thank you.
  26. doomwhistle started following PGM - Hulk 140
  27. doomwhistle
    Hey gang! Thinking of resubmitting this. I sent it in ages and ages ago without a cleaning or press. It scored a 9.2 w/ "off white to white pages" but I feel it's worthy of a higher grade. To my semi novice eyes, it looks like a higher grade. Whaddya think? Crack and resend in for higher grade? A thousand thank yous.
  28.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: PGM - New Mutants #87
  29.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: PGM - New Mutants #87
  30.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: PGM - New Mutants #87
  31.    doomwhistle reacted to a post in a topic: PGM - New Mutants #87
  32. doomwhistle
    Good catch…it is glare.
  33. doomwhistle
    Hello all, Thoughts on this book? I am planning to submit for C/P and grading. Thanks!
  34. doomwhistle
    Thanks for all the feedback. I think I will send it in.
  35.    scburdet reacted to a post in a topic: PGM ASM #238
  36. doomwhistle
    Well, I was planning on CGC handling the C/P. Hoping they would be aware of this.
  37. doomwhistle
    Thanks. Ya, did the flashlight test. It's all there. 9.0/9.2 after C/P?
  38. doomwhistle
    Hello, Thinking of sending this in for a CP and grade. Thoughts?