• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Just Visiting

Member
  • Posts

    190
  • Joined

Everything posted by Just Visiting

  1. I got walloped on War Action. , I had Silver Surfer at 5.0, did the fading of part of the cover not affect the grade?
  2. Some markings on the front cover also, Red Barbarian's left hand fingernails have been colored in, lines drawn on the hand and his mouth also. Maybe this person was just bored. I don't think it will make any difference at this grade. I could be wrong. 3.0
  3. 6.5 also but it is hard to disagree with Galen130 at 7.0
  4. I'm leaning on the 3.5 also
  5. My guesstimate 3.5
  6. Gotta say 5.0 also
  7. I'll say 4.5/5.0 as is
  8. I had my copy graded a few years ago and it got a 7.0 not cleaned or pressed. debating whether to resubmit with a C&P
  9. "grotty" now that's a word I haven't heard in a while. Not since that old B&W movie of my favorite band. I had MS5 at 3.5 it just looked pretty bad.
  10. My HTD #1 has the same pink bleed thru and the marks at the top but I could not see this book at 9.6. Had it this one marked 9.2/9.0 I chose 9.0
  11. I gave Crime Suspenstories a 3.5 Had it marked 3.0 but gave it a Golden age bump. Thought that was normal for GA books.
  12. ......... Wait a minute, what am I laughing at that could very well be me!!!!
  13. I am in no way an expert but I'll take a shot at it 2.5/3.0
  14. I didn't sleep well a couple nights after I posted my grades for round 2 and I blame Mike for the Emoji that is still haunting me so I waited this time till just a little while ago.
  15. I was at 6.5 and sticking with that