Bayowolf

OK, next time. Definitely worth getting graded.

Thanks. I thought with all the tape it might not even hit 2.0!

9.0

8.5

Maybe even 8.0!I think CGC gives a little extra to golden age books.

Hard to grade with this collage of pics. And get your finger out of the way..

8.0 to 9.0 range. Better pics, scans would help pin it down. Use backgrounds that are one solid color and keep it constant,

5.5

One copy per post please.

On 11/13/2021 at 9:13 PM, grendelbo said:

Welcome. Thanks for posting.

Refer to PGM Guidelines pinned to the top of the board. 

You'll need to take the comicbook out of the bag and preferred pics are front and back cover with better detail of all 4 corners and edges of both sides.

Ditto

I don't se that much wrong with this..I was thinking 9.0.

This is one of my most beat up comics. Many flaws. Also, if you can't tell, the entire spine is taped on the outside of both the front and back covers; not to keep the cover on - it is attached via the staples -but because the spine has so  many tears that pieces would fall off. I know this is a "beater" or reader- it is complete. 

Complete.

Thanks

9.0

1.5/2.0

8.0

6.0

On 11/10/2021 at 8:42 PM, FFB said:

6.5 to 7.0 due to staining if it's limited to the cover and not the interior pages.

Agree. FC is pretty good, but back staining, ouch! 

6.5

7.0 train

8.0/8.5

Should it be dinged for the FC roll a bit to the back? If so 6.5 otherwise 7.0

Staples are tarnished. Complete. 

Thanks

7.0 CP to 8.0

7.5/8.0 clean to 8.5/9.0

CP -press should take out that crease near spine....8.0 as is, CP to 8.5 or 9.0