Christophe9999

That's surprising to me. There's a significant color breaking tic and not sure what you call that long line. Plus the wear on the upper right top corner I feel like these combined and still getting a 9.6 questionable.

I'm curious if this Hulk 181 is the one where they created a duplicate label but with a higher grade. Can having these defects still score a 9.6? This was in a batch of 5 books submitted on 9/8/2023. One of the books sold on ebay from these folks. Grader's note only says "very small crease left top of back cover".

Multiple MJ 9.8s in that submission 5/20/21 3806823003 - ASM 294 9.8 Mark Jewelers 3806823004 - ASM 301 9.8 Mark jewelers 3806823005 - ASM 303 9.8 Mark jewelers 3806823007 - ASM 306 9.8 Mark jewelers 3806823010 - ASM 308 9.8 Mark Jewelers

It would be great if CGC gave a $5 credit towards grading or something to return labels. Keeps the census clean and incentivizes people to return CPR labels. It's a win-win.

It will be interesting to see how this all plays out but eBay is not incentivized to do anything. Let's not forget they collected thousands in fees from these sales. Not sure what eBay would do for a buyer that purchased something months ago that was fraudulent. They might not even care. I've heard some horror stories from people dealing with their support. I will say that I work for a law enforcement agency and we have investigators that have worked with eBay for gathering evidence. eBay will provide that but of course this is because a law enforcement agency has brought up a case and is requesting the data. I don't see eBay cooperating if it's just a customer trying to resolve these fraudulent sales.

yes it's the same seller

Beyond a shadow of a doubt these are the same books. I upped the contrast on the green label to better see.

oops did the wrong screenshot on the auctions

Oh wait never mind they did relist it.

Correct me if I'm wrong but I thought if an item is relisted it says so.

I'm thinking 9.0 - 9.2

ok cool, thank you

Hey guys, if your membership auto renews do you get another $150 credit towards grading?

Well the fact that they didn't even get the stripes on the flag right says a lot. Pure money grab all around. Black Flag doesn't deserve anyone's business.

for what you get it's actually not that bad of a deal. I prefer to use the solid boxes they offer anyway plus it comes with bags and boards.