Mini Contest

[nik]

Going to recheck the scoring tonight. But based on what I think is accurate, we have 3 people tied with 40 points

 

and 2 eliminations :tonofbricks:

[BlowUpTheMoon]

 

and 2 eliminations :tonofbricks:

 

:tonofbricks:

[greggy]

And the results according to CGC

 

 

 

1 Journey Into Mystery 123 - CGC 8.5

 

2 Iron Man 51 - CGC 9.6

 

3 Wonder Woman 181 - CGC 9.2

 

4 Iron Man 48 - CGC 9.2

 

5 JLA 70 - CGC 9.2

 

6 Conan 9 - CGC 9.4

 

7 Witching Hour 10 - CGC 9.2

 

8 Conan 10 - CGC 9.4

 

9 Jungle Action 5 - CGC 9.6

 

Daredevil 103 - CGC 9.2

Sweet, all 9.2s with the DCs

[nik]

[greggy]

I win again

[Mac Man]

Well, not too bad. Looks I only overgraded once and it was one grade off, 3 dead hits, and the rest only undergraded by 1. Looks like I got around 32 points or so, and if the winning score was 40, I guess I did well enough to hold my own here :shrug:

[Sal]

36. whoopee. it was totally worth the wait.

 

got the two Iron Man books exactly backwards, or i would have had 44. can't see how book four got a 9.6 and book 2 only a 9.2...unless the gook in the logo of book 2 is what did it.

 

or back cover damage.

[trmoore54]

And the results according to CGC

 

 

 

1 Journey Into Mystery 123 - CGC 8.5

 

2 Iron Man 51 - CGC 9.6

 

3 Wonder Woman 181 - CGC 9.2

 

4 Iron Man 48 - CGC 9.2

 

5 JLA 70 - CGC 9.2

 

6 Conan 9 - CGC 9.4

 

7 Witching Hour 10 - CGC 9.2

 

8 Conan 10 - CGC 9.4

 

9 Jungle Action 5 - CGC 9.6

 

Daredevil 103 - CGC 9.2

 

Nik...I can't find my pics/grades...can you tell me what my score was? THANKS! Tom

[nik]

I will get to everyones scores tonight (thumbs u

[BlowUpTheMoon]

You nailed alot of your own scores. On the other hand, I didn't. Here's my breakdown:

 

 

5x5 = 25

4x3 = 12

1x(-3) = -3

37+ (-3) = 34

 

I was way off on book one (8.5) that gave me that -3

[october]

36. whoopee. it was totally worth the wait.

 

got the two Iron Man books exactly backwards, or i would have had 44. can't see how book four got a 9.6 and book 2 only a 9.2...unless the gook in the logo of book 2 is what did it.

 

or back cover damage.

 

I got a 36 too. I was within one step on every book except the WH 10. I had that at an 8.5....what a gift at 9.2!

 

Fun contest Nik. (thumbs u

[divad]

And the results according to CGC

 

 

 

1 Journey Into Mystery 123 - CGC 8.5

 

2 Iron Man 51 - CGC 9.6

 

3 Wonder Woman 181 - CGC 9.2

 

4 Iron Man 48 - CGC 9.2

 

5 JLA 70 - CGC 9.2

 

6 Conan 9 - CGC 9.4

 

7 Witching Hour 10 - CGC 9.2

 

8 Conan 10 - CGC 9.4

 

9 Jungle Action 5 - CGC 9.6

 

Daredevil 103 - CGC 9.2

 

Can somebody do the math for me . . .

 

1 JIM 123 8.5

2 IM 51 9.2

3 WW 181 9.4

4 IM 48 9.2

5 JLA 70 9.4

6 C 9 9.4

7 TWH 10 9.0

8 C 10 9.6

9 BP 5 9.4

10 DD 103 9.4

 

 

 

10 books for this contest. Points will be awarded as follows.

 

5 points - Nailing the grade

 

3 points - 1 grade off

 

1 point - 2 grades off

 

minus 2 points - 3 grades off

 

DQ - 4 grades off

[Ze-man]

I made it easy, I guessed 9.4 across the board except for a 9.0 on that JIM.

 

Still ended up with 33 points

 

[divad]

34 3-nailed, 6-almosts and 1-WTF!

 

Great scoring system!

 

Loads of fun! Thanks Nik!

[toro]

I made it easy, I guessed 9.4 across the board except for a 9.0 on that JIM.

 

Still ended up with 33 points

 

 

I should have done that!!! Only nailed one.

 

But only off by one on 8. Missed by 2 on one! Only got a 30!

[Comicdey]

 

 

5 points - Nailing the grade

 

3 points - 1 grade off

 

1 point - 2 grades off

 

minus 2 points - 3 grades off

 

DQ - 4 grades off

 

My grades....I gave the NIK bump in a few cases....

9.2

9.4

9.4

9.4

9.6

9.4

9.2

9.4

9.4

9.2

 

 

1 - 8.5 (2 off) 1

 

2 - 9.4 (correct) 5

 

3 - 9.4 (correct) 5

 

4 - 9.4 (correct) 5

 

5 - 9.2 (2 off) 1

 

6 - 9.4 (correct) 5

 

7 - 9.0 (1 off) 3

 

8 - 9.6 (1 off) 3

 

9 - 9.4 (correct) 5

 

10 - 9.2 (correct) 5

 

38 points....

[Aces]

1) JIM 123 9.0 nice book

 

2) IM 51 9.6 cause it's you

 

3) WW 181 9.4 it's a DC

 

4) IM 48 9.6 thought about 9.8 here...

 

5) JLA 70 9.2 shoulda got that corner pressed

 

6) Conan 9 9.8

 

7) WH 10 9.2 maybe 9.0; dark cover DC horror gets it worse than anything

 

8) Conan 10 9.6

 

9) JA 5 9.4

 

10) DD 103 9.2 that one may have been a waste...

 

 

4 x 5

4 x 3

2 x 1

 

34 pts

Not bad for no back cover scans.

 

Went with too much bump on books 4 and 6.

[Comicdey]

That was fun..thanks NIK

[Comicdey]

I figured nik wouldn't even send in a book that was below a 9.0....

[MCMiles]

36 for me also, I got hammered on the Iron Man. I only gave it a 9.2.