PGM FF 23

[rube11]

This book has a nice subscription crease and overall nice appeal. I think without the crease it would grade in the 5.5 range but maybe now closer to the 3.5/4.0 range?

 

 

[Blind Owl]

One of my favorite FF issues..... (thumbs u

 

I've owned several copies of this book over the years..and even with the subscription crease I'd still call this book a 5.0 copy.

 

 

I'm sure alot of the CGC 9.8 club will be jumping all over me for saying that....but I has seen worse looking copies get a 5.0. I've also seen better looking copies get a 4.5..so go figure....let's compromise and call it at least a 4.5 copy.

 

I think 3.5/4.0 is too low. But what do I know...look where I finished in the grading contest....

[Boozad]

I'd go for a 4.5 (thumbs u

[Mio]

Probable 4.5, possible 4.0. Lower than that seems needlessly harsh to me.

[Limited66]

4.5

[ComicDoc]

4.0

[ROBTOTHEC]

Hey Steve, I think that is definitely a 4.5!

I would be fine getting it at that grade.

[MagnetoWasRight]

yeah, 4.5 definitely

[rube11]

Looks like the overall concensus is 4.5, thank you for the grading service. Time to move them over to the for sale section!

 

Steve

[davidking623]

4.0

 

Davidking623