PGM: ASM 101

[1904 Comics]

Top staple pushed in. Back Cover top edges. Feedback appreciated! (thumbs u

 

[zosocane]

5.0. Maybe 5.5

[ROBTOTHEC]

4.5, maybe 5.0. I despise detached staples.

 

[vaillant]

I’d say 4.0 because I would have given it a 6.0 and I calculate two points less for the cover detached at one staple. I hate this defect but I think this is how CGC treats it objectively. Maybe a 4.5.

 

Hey, would you be so nice to grade my Captain Britaim magazine #14?

No one is doing it…

[zosocane]

You guys are right, the staple pull (not a detached staple) means it's a 4.5.

[roulette44]

5.0/5.5 assuming staple not detached, just pushed in (as you described)

[vaillant]

I think the staple is detached (at least from the picture).

However, as I said even with a detached staple should not be more than 2 points less.

[BarryAllen]

4.5