PGM Giant size Xmen 1

[Mongkorn]

Hi all,

 

Im upgrading my collection and wonder if i should try to ebay raw or just grade and keep. Thanks in advance and greatly appreciate any input!

 

 

 

 

 

The glaring issue to me is the corner here.

 

 

[jsilverjanet]

7.0 however I suck at grading these thick books

[oakman29]

7.0 sounds about right.

[Hado]

I was thinking 7.0/7.5 but square bound books confuse me, nice book

[Mongkorn]

Thanks for the insight and quick responses!

[BarryAllen]

6.5-7.0

 

I am with the group that square bound books are tough to grade. The obvious concern is that stubbed top corner...

[The-Collector]

6.5.

[fastballspecial]

Far right corner also is a concern for me. All say 7.0 right in that area.

 

[Mongkorn]

Im not saying the books are otherwise similar but ive seen this book with a similar dent graded at 9.2....??

 

Oh well, i get that the thick ones are hard to grade.

 

Thanks a bunch!

[oakman29]

Im not saying the books are otherwise similar but ive seen this book with a similar dent graded at 9.2....??

 

Oh well, i get that the thick ones are hard to grade.

 

Thanks a bunch!

I think not!

[Lost]

 

 

actually I've seen the bad spine corner on these thick bounds on some 9.4's...

 

[1904 Comics]

7.0

[Mongkorn]

 

actually I've seen the bad spine corner on these thick bounds on some 9.4's...

 

 

 

 

So your saying theres a chance.....

[youmechooz]

 

actually I've seen the bad spine corner on these thick bounds on some 9.4's...

 

 

 

 

So your saying theres a chance.....

 

not at all, book is a 6.5 all day but will hit a 7.0 if you send it in.

[Mongkorn]

thats cold..but the truth hurts

[Lost]

 

actually I've seen the bad spine corner on these thick bounds on some 9.4's...

 

 

 

 

So your saying theres a chance.....

 

 

Haha but that was the only thing wrong with the book and it was a little less noticeable...I give yours a 6.5. But if you manage to get them to grade it on a Friday... it could hit 7.0.