PGM Tales to astonish 28

[southerncross]

This book has very good eye appeal but the grade it would be is not too high.

Like to hear what you think this book grade is. No hidden defects and there is a diagonal crease that runs from under the bottom staple up to right hand edge of the cover thru the top right panel on the front cover. Thanks

[Boboset]

5.0/5.5

 

But obviously presents much better. My point of comparison is a Mass ped early Iron Man TOS that presented 9.4 save for a partially breaking but long running fc crease. That graded 6.0

[timfinz]

This book looks better than the 4.5 I'm giving it. All mainly due to the extent of the crease on the front cover. Maybe CGC would not grade as harsh... I don't know?

[rjpb]

5.0

[cpannell]

Very pretty copy. It's a shame it won't get more than a 5.0 by CGC rules.

 

Of course, I might be wrong.

 

[johnny54321]

I'd grade 4.5 due to the crease, but it presents more like a 6.5, so CGC may go a bit higher.

[southerncross]

Thanks for your time looking and the grades given .

[MR SigS]

5.0

[tjanse]

5.0/5.5