Compare the grades...Guess the grades , whatever.

[notch_top]

Pretty nuts for that 9.8 ...I am not so sure they actually sold? As I was offered the lot indirectly for $10k. (121, 122)

 

I pregraded the 8.5 as a 9.2 so we agree there, the 9.6 I bought slabbed and got a good deal from a very respected dealer and blazing member.

 

After going through many 9.4's and a few 9.6's I can tell you that the 9.6 structurally is a very nice copy , compared to those I have seen and flipped.

 

Current bronze market is not my forte..But I would estimate the 8.5 to sell for $150.00. a 9.2 for $300, and a 9.6 for .$1000-$2000 depending on what BSD is looking at it.

 

9.6's are as we all know an entire separate category.

 

Any one interested in the 8.5 pm me , it is for sale.

 

Naturally as my other thread in comics general suggests, I would resub it.

 

M

 

 

[Guest]

I was close.....I graded the top one a 9.0 and the bottom a 9.4!

[blowout]

its amazing how many people think the bottom book looks better since you released the grades...

I also find it easier to grade a book once someone tells me what the grade is. Nice one guys, try posting your grades BEFORE they are revealed.

 

I still think the top book looks better. Thanks Notch Top for posting these books, it convinces me (if I wasn't before) to stay away from silver/bronze 9.6s.

[Crowzilla]

He didn't give it enough time.

First time I saw the thread I thought the books were 9.0 and 9.4, but as I'm scrolling down, he's already got the grades posted - not much you can do then.

 

[Illiterati-migration]

It doesn't make sense as the colors surrounding that area are bright and vibid as the rest of the cover is.

 

Yeah, they look bright and vivid, but it's also yellow and I think with a lighter color like yellow (and obviously the white box underneath the bar), it would be tougher to identify color fade like that. But yeah, this is a toughie. Haven't you contacted CGC for the grader's notes?