PGM: ASM #1- Test Your Skill - Book is slabbed - See Page 5 for Better pic

[Diaolos]

Wondering if your grading skills are those used by CGC? I wanted to make this fun. Below is my ASM #1. Pulled it from Safe Keying to get it signed by Stan Lee soon. Before it's sent off to be signed and re-slabbed what do you think this book was graded by CGC. Gook Luck...

 

Book has white pages

 

 

 

[faster friends]

4.5

[silverweb]

fuzzy picture!

significant Marvel chipping at upper right edge. cant tell if there are any creases or tears. Maybe 5.0 from what I can see

[paul747]

6.5 ? Hard picture to really see. Book looks really nice besides chipping . Can't tell if there is browning on edges. Spine looks nice from pic.

 

6.0

[Primetime]

Hard to see the scan. Looks like chipping on the edge but its clean otherwise. I've seen CGC call books as high as 6.5 with chipping. I'll say 5.0/5.5.

[jsilverjanet]

Hard to see the scan. Looks like chipping on the edge but its clean otherwise. I've seen CGC call books as high as 6.5 with chipping. I'll say 5.0/5.5.

+1 on CGC giving books high grades with chipping

 

6.0 is my guess

 

 

[timfinz]

love it but I can barely make it out!

7.0 IMHO!

[bedrockcomics]

Looks exactly like the book I looked at last week...Only wasn't slabbed

[Diaolos]

Yah I know scans are not great but best my scanner can do while books is slabbed.

 

Took pictures they are better but not by much

 

 

 

[Diaolos]

I have had this for 1 year and it was slabbed

[faster friends]

5.5

[Hulksdaddy1]

6.5

[AnhDepTrai]

5.0

[Diaolos]

Any comments about a press being beneficial or not would be appreciated.

[thunsicker]

I'm at 6.5. Press May or may not be beneficial. If CGC graded it 4.5 I'd try a press. If they graded it 7.5 I'd never ever crack it.

[bighairjer]

6.0

[DeadpoolJr.]

5.5

[timfinz]

In light of the new pictures I'll still stand by my 7.0!

[Red84]

6.5

[eeb03]

6.0