Signature Series Bizarre Question

[THE_BEYONDER]

BTW- I have 2 copies of IF 15 that say " John Byrne written on first page in pen/marker"

 

One's an old red label, and the other is a blue label prior to the removal of "NM" from the label.

 

The only ones that say "NAME" are the ones that have a sig on the front cover.

The ones on the inside of the book seem to list what is written in them.

 

Guess they figure if you can read it yourself...there's no need to put it in print.

 

Kinda like QP label notations...

[Mephisto]

BTW- I have 2 copies of IF 15 that say " John Byrne written on first page in pen/marker"

 

One's an old red label, and the other is a blue label prior to the removal of "NM" from the label.

 

The only ones that say "NAME" are the ones that have a sig on the front cover.

The ones on the inside of the book seem to list what is written in them.

 

I think they may have changed the policy and they all state name now.

 

Here is the one I found earlier that says "Terry Austin" written on 1st page.

http://www.heritagecomics.com/common/view_item.php?Sale_No=14061&Lot_No=16737&src=pr

 

And this one says "3 Names" written on 1st page

http://www.heritagecomics.com/common/view_item.php?Sale_No=14061&Lot_No=16250&src=pr

[THE_BEYONDER]

. I hope folks appreciate the implications in the question.

 

 

To be completely honest...I have no idea what you're trying to get at.

[DiceX]

BTW- I have 2 copies of IF 15 that say " John Byrne written on first page in pen/marker"

 

One's an old red label, and the other is a blue label prior to the removal of "NM" from the label.

 

The only ones that say "NAME" are the ones that have a sig on the front cover.

The ones on the inside of the book seem to list what is written in them.

 

Guess they figure if you can read it yourself...there's no need to put it in print.

 

Kinda like QP label notations...

 

It's all kinda irrelevant. I know who signed it, and it will be placed in my coffin when I die.

 

My wife says I have..."issues".

[THE_BEYONDER]

BTW- I have 2 copies of IF 15 that say " John Byrne written on first page in pen/marker"

 

One's an old red label, and the other is a blue label prior to the removal of "NM" from the label.

 

The only ones that say "NAME" are the ones that have a sig on the front cover.

The ones on the inside of the book seem to list what is written in them.

 

Guess they figure if you can read it yourself...there's no need to put it in print.

 

Kinda like QP label notations...

 

It's all kinda irrelevant. I know who signed it, and it will be placed in my coffin when I die.

 

My wife says I have..."issues".

 

no comment

[Mephisto]

BTW- I have 2 copies of IF 15 that say " John Byrne written on first page in pen/marker"

 

One's an old red label, and the other is a blue label prior to the removal of "NM" from the label.

 

The only ones that say "NAME" are the ones that have a sig on the front cover.

The ones on the inside of the book seem to list what is written in them.

 

Guess they figure if you can read it yourself...there's no need to put it in print.

 

Kinda like QP label notations...

 

It's all kinda irrelevant. I know who signed it, and it will be placed in my coffin when I die.

 

My wife says I have..."issues".

 

no comment

 

I bet you want to be buried in the same coffin as Byrne.

[THE_BEYONDER]

I bet you want to be buried in the same coffin as Byrne.

 

 

How much?

[PovertyRow]

. I hope folks appreciate the implications in the question.

 

 

To be completely honest...I have no idea what you're trying to get at.

 

OK - I will simplify it as much as I can. No - I am simplifying so let me say

 

Me make simple.

 

CGC says "we saw person sign."

CGC makes pretty yellow label.

CGC puts strange words "Signature Series" on pretty yellow label.

How does CGC know the human who put name on book is the human they say put name on book?

 

"Come back! I was going to make espresso!"

[THE_BEYONDER]

. I hope folks appreciate the implications in the question.

 

 

To be completely honest...I have no idea what you're trying to get at.

 

OK - I will simplify it as much as I can. No - I am simplifying so let me say

 

Me make simple.

 

CGC says "we saw person sign."

CGC makes pretty yellow label.

CGC puts strange words "Signature Series" on pretty yellow label.

How does CGC know the human who put name on book is the human they say put name on book?

 

"Come back! I was going to make espresso!"

 

Are you suggesting that people are going around to conventions and pretending to be famous comic artists & writers?

 

 

 

 

[DiceX]

BTW- I have 2 copies of IF 15 that say " John Byrne written on first page in pen/marker"

 

One's an old red label, and the other is a blue label prior to the removal of "NM" from the label.

 

The only ones that say "NAME" are the ones that have a sig on the front cover.

The ones on the inside of the book seem to list what is written in them.

 

Guess they figure if you can read it yourself...there's no need to put it in print.

 

Kinda like QP label notations...

 

It's all kinda irrelevant. I know who signed it, and it will be placed in my coffin when I die.

 

My wife says I have..."issues".

 

no comment

 

I bet you want to be buried in the same coffin as Byrne.

 

Is he on top, or on bottom?

[PovertyRow]

. I hope folks appreciate the implications in the question.

 

 

To be completely honest...I have no idea what you're trying to get at.

 

OK - I will simplify it as much as I can. No - I am simplifying so let me say

 

Me make simple.

 

CGC says "we saw person sign."

CGC makes pretty yellow label.

CGC puts strange words "Signature Series" on pretty yellow label.

How does CGC know the human who put name on book is the human they say put name on book?

 

"Come back! I was going to make espresso!"

 

Are you suggesting that people are going around to conventions and pretending to be famous comic artists & writers?

 

 

 

 

 

NOT

 

Not at all.

 

THIS is what I am saying - seriously - please at least for one post attend to the REAL question.

 

CGC does two things abbout signatures.

 

1) Refuses to acknowledge them if they are not signed in their presence.

 

2) Acknowledges them with the Yellow Sig Series label if signed in their presence.

 

So, seriously, can you please just address this question: What criteria does CGC use to definitively authenticate the individual whose signature they are authenticating?

 

Do you really think this is a stupid question? Can you imagine a court case where CGC says "Well, I know what they look and sound like so I know they are who they say they are?"

 

How would such testimony be seen?

 

There is no question the Sig Series can demand premium over guide. I am just wondering what steps CGC takes to insure their authentication.

[THE_BEYONDER]

. I hope folks appreciate the implications in the question.

 

 

To be completely honest...I have no idea what you're trying to get at.

 

OK - I will simplify it as much as I can. No - I am simplifying so let me say

 

Me make simple.

 

CGC says "we saw person sign."

CGC makes pretty yellow label.

CGC puts strange words "Signature Series" on pretty yellow label.

How does CGC know the human who put name on book is the human they say put name on book?

 

"Come back! I was going to make espresso!"

 

Are you suggesting that people are going around to conventions and pretending to be famous comic artists & writers?

 

 

 

 

 

NOT

 

Not at all.

 

THIS is what I am saying - seriously - please at least for one post attend to the REAL question.

 

CGC does two things abbout signatures.

 

1) Refuses to acknowledge them if they are not signed in their presence.

 

2) Acknowledges them with the Yellow Sig Series label if signed in their presence.

 

So, seriously, can you please just address this question: What criteria does CGC use to definitively authenticate the individual whose signature they are authenticating?

 

Do you really think this is a stupid question? Can you imagine a court case where CGC says "Well, I know what they look and sound like so I know they are who they say they are?"

 

How would such testimony be seen?

 

There is no question the Sig Series can demand premium over guide. I am just wondering what steps CGC takes to insure their authentication.

 

Gotcha

 

You're wondering how CGC would prove after the fact that a specific artist actually signed the book in question...?

[DiceX]

. I hope folks appreciate the implications in the question.

 

 

To be completely honest...I have no idea what you're trying to get at.

 

OK - I will simplify it as much as I can. No - I am simplifying so let me say

 

Me make simple.

 

CGC says "we saw person sign."

CGC makes pretty yellow label.

CGC puts strange words "Signature Series" on pretty yellow label.

How does CGC know the human who put name on book is the human they say put name on book?

 

"Come back! I was going to make espresso!"

 

Are you suggesting that people are going around to conventions and pretending to be famous comic artists & writers?

 

 

 

 

 

NOT

 

Not at all.

 

THIS is what I am saying - seriously - please at least for one post attend to the REAL question.

 

CGC does two things abbout signatures.

 

1) Refuses to acknowledge them if they are not signed in their presence.

 

2) Acknowledges them with the Yellow Sig Series label if signed in their presence.

 

So, seriously, can you please just address this question: What criteria does CGC use to definitively authenticate the individual whose signature they are authenticating?

 

Do you really think this is a stupid question? Can you imagine a court case where CGC says "Well, I know what they look and sound like so I know they are who they say they are?"

 

How would such testimony be seen?

 

There is no question the Sig Series can demand premium over guide. I am just wondering what steps CGC takes to insure their authentication.

 

Gotcha

 

You're wondering how CGC would prove after the fact that a specific artist actually signed the book in question...?

 

Sounds like a logical question.

[PovertyRow]

You're wondering how CGC would prove after the fact that a specific artist actually signed the book in question...?

 

FINALLY! Gawd yes! YES! Thank you!

[THE_BEYONDER]

You're wondering how CGC would prove after the fact that a specific artist actually signed the book in question...?

 

FINALLY! Gawd yes! YES! Thank you!

 

Hmm...

[greggy]

[DiceX]

 

Where have you been?

[greggy]

 

Where have you been?

Here fool! I'm always around Cowboy!

[DiceX]

 

Where have you been?

Here fool! I'm always around Cowboy!

 

There have been multiple graemlin war threads, and not a peep from you.

You're slipping.

 

And I have tickets to the game tomorrow.

Be sure to put on some orange and cheer them on.

[greggy]

 

Where have you been?

Here fool! I'm always around Cowboy!

 

There have been multiple graemlin war threads, and not a peep from you.

You're slipping.

 

And I have tickets to the game tomorrow.

Be sure to put on some orange and cheer them on.

You guys are losers for ruining this fine thread. So...screw you loser!