The Finals: Dark Knight #1-4 vs Watchmen #1-12

[BachelorOfComix]

This one will Tug on the Soul for a bit might have to go reread them both - when is shilling, er I mean voting up? Kudos to Alex for taking the voting to PM.

 

Has is really been 20 years man so thats what Pov, Hook and Burnt feel like. My impression is that I think DKR had more exposure, it was certainly hyped more, especially after the 2nd issue. The story and art on both are excellent, it truly is a

 

No it's not, just vote for DKR and be done with it.

 

I'm almost certain FFB meant to say Watchmen just then jbud.

 

Remember Moore is more!!!! So don't vote for the upstart Miller.

 

Watchmen was BORING. Just in case you missed it the first time, I'll say it again -- Watchmen was BORING.

 

DKR kicked serious butt and redefined a character that people STILL care about today.

I totally agree.

[uclapeterg]

ummm, you know Alex is not counting your vote if you are telling who you voted for, right???

[FFB]

ummm, you know Alex is not counting your vote if you are telling who you voted for, right???

 

Not a single person in this thread has said who he voted for. We're just each ripping one side apart, that's all.

[goldust40]

ummm, you know Alex is not counting your vote if you are telling who you voted for, right???

 

Not a single person in this thread has said who he voted for. We're just each ripping one side apart, that's all.

 

Alex is only accepting PMs, anyway. So you can broadcast your vote, it makes no difference.

 

So who're you voting for, FFB?

[FFB]

ummm, you know Alex is not counting your vote if you are telling who you voted for, right???

 

Not a single person in this thread has said who he voted for. We're just each ripping one side apart, that's all.

 

Alex is only accepting PMs, anyway. So you can broadcast your vote, it makes no difference.

 

So who're you voting for, FFB?

 

Senator Vinick!!!!!

[Ares]

ummm, you know Alex is not counting your vote if you are telling who you voted for, right???

 

Not a single person in this thread has said who he voted for. We're just each ripping one side apart, that's all.

 

Dork Knight Returns

Duck Knight Returns

Dumb Knight Returns

Dark Overweight could find a way to fit it in contunuity Knight

 

We all know the better story

Watchmen #1-12

[FlyingDonut]

I am not voting, but if I did, I'd vote for the most influential book of the past 20 years. Here's a hint, it doesn't have more than 4 issues.

[FlyingDonut]

Plus, it gave us the funniest parody comic ever:

 

somebody fix this so the link shows the image

[Lantern]

Plus, it gave us the funniest parody comic ever:

 

somebody fix this so the link shows the image

 

[FFB]

Plus, it gave us the funniest parody comic ever:

 

somebody fix this so the link shows the image

 

I don't know about you, but I consider DC's Doom Force Special to be the funniest parody comic ever.

[jbud73]

I am not voting, but if I did, I'd vote for the most influential book of the past 20 years. Here's a hint, it doesn't have more than 4 issues.

 

Not voting how un-democratic of you FD. Nice comback by Illy tonight great game. Finally cast my vote, tough choice felt like Charlie Sheen in Platoon.

[AlexH]

Don't forget to vote. You have until Noon today.

[AlexH]

Before I announce the winner, I would like to say thanks to everyone who enjoyed the contest. It has been a wild ride, and I hope you guys had fun. Now on to the good stuff:

 

The winner and grand champion, beating out 80+ other contestants:

 

Dark Knight #1-4

22 votes 67%

 

Watchmen #1-12

11 votes 33%

 

Its now over...

[BachelorOfComix]

[Wally's Comics]

BatMan Forever!

[rob_react]

[chrisco37]

Damn Miller shills.

 

C'mon, Goldy! Get your dolls. We're outta here.

[Norrin_Radd]

Damn Miller shills.

 

C'mon, Goldy! Get your dolls. We're outta here.

 

 

 

[goldust40]

Damn Miller shills.

 

C'mon, Goldy! Get your dolls. We're outta here.

 

Yeah, leave the heathens to their upstart false Gods - we'll set up our own contest where the winner is guaranteed from the outset.

 

It'll be totally different to this one.

[AlexH]

Damn Miller shills.

 

C'mon, Goldy! Get your dolls. We're outta here.

 

Yeah, leave the heathens to their upstart false Gods - we'll set up our own contest where the winner is guaranteed from the outset.

 

It'll be totally different to this one.

 

Are you implying something Captain red pants?