Please grade my Flash 153

[rube11]

The bottom right hand corner looks funny in the scan but it is a sharp corner.

 

Thanks,

Steve

 

[uclapeterg]

definitely a 9.0+ candidate.

[ericc123]

I want to buy it! 9.2/9.4

[rube11]

I am HOPING iit comes back at LEAST 9.4. I am waiting for CGC. But the book is a killer copy. The back cover is really nice also.

 

Rube

[divad]

definitely a 9.0+ candidate.

 

You wouldn't know a 9.4 if it hit you like a truck

 

[divad]

I am HOPING iit comes back at LEAST 9.4. I am waiting for CGC. But the book is a killer copy. The back cover is really nice also.

 

Rube

 

I do believe you've got a 9.6 there Rube - keep us posted

[uclapeterg]

definitely a 9.0+ candidate.

 

You wouldn't know a 9.4 if it hit you like a truck

 

 

I was going to write a 9.4+ candidate so .

 

I feel uncomfortable grading above 9.4, even if I think a book is perfect.

[Aces]

9.4

[divad]

definitely a 9.0+ candidate.

 

You wouldn't know a 9.4 if it hit you like a truck

 

 

I was going to write a 9.4+ candidate so .

 

I feel uncomfortable grading above 9.4, even if I think a book is perfect.

 

[uclapeterg]

9.4

 

That must mean it's a 9.2.

[rube11]

Wow,

 

Taking no prisoners here I see!!! You can just feel the love!

 

[Aces]

9.4

 

That must mean it's a 9.2.

 

Only if it was a greggy book.

[burntboy]

Wow,

 

Taking no prisoners here I see!!! You can just feel the love!

 

 

when a scan that BIG shows virtually NO defects (except that funky corner which you said is sharp), you have a 9.6 candidate. IMHO.....................

 

if it comes back less than 9.4, you lied to us about the back cover.......

[Crackandpresstoan11]

9.2, maybe 9.4. It would be a 9.6 if it was a Marvel.

[burntboy]

9.2, maybe 9.4. It would be a 9.6 if it was a Marvel.

 

i just said almost the same thing in FFB's Adventure comic grading thread. take a look at the two 7.5's that I just got graded.......................................

[Crackandpresstoan11]

Based on your scans, I wouldn't have a problem w/ you calling those 8.5's. I break all of the CGC books I buy out of the slabs (regardless of grade) , so I get a better look at graded books than most people. I would say 75% of the time, DC's are graded more harshly than Marvels... and the older the book, the wider the difference ( in regards to silver, anyway).

[divad]

I get a better look at graded books than most people.

 

Man, you DO think highly of yourself . . . what about those of us who actually submit the books

 

[Crackandpresstoan11]

When you submit a book, the book leaves your hands for MONTHS. Even if you have a scan of the book before slabbing, it is usually not a substitute for examining the book, raw, in person. Can you remember every inch of a book months after the last time you saw it raw?? Breaking the book from a slab gives you the benefit of already knowing the grade and seeing the book raw, as opposed to trying to remember how good a book looks outside of a slab. And shouldn't everyone think highly of themselves?

[divad]

When you submit a book, the book leaves your hands for MONTHS. Even if you have a scan of the book before slabbing, it is usually not a substitute for examining the book, raw, in person. Can you remember every inch of a book months after the last time you saw it raw?? Breaking the book from a slab gives you the benefit of already knowing the grade and seeing the book raw, as opposed to trying to remember how good a book looks outside of a slab.

 

I don't entirely disagree, I've broken out plenty of books. And yes, I remember every detail about a book (unless I was out of it when I sent it in . . .

 

And shouldn't everyone think highly of themselves?

 

Yes, and if they did, they wouldn't post a mug like that as their avatar!

[nik]

And shouldn't everyone think highly of themselves?

My kids think highly of me