Please grade my Flash 153

[Crackandpresstoan11]

I don't entirely disagree, I've broken out plenty of books. And yes, I remember every detail about a book (unless I was out of it when I sent it in . . .

 

Then I guess you have a spectacular memory.

 

Yes, and if they did, they wouldn't post a mug like that as their avatar!

 

In case it's over your head, that's not me.... It's everybody's favorite American Idol, the amazing Scott Savol

 

I guess you have a long white beard and wear a yellow dress?

[Fan4Fan]

In case it's over your head, that's not me.... It's everybody's favorite American Idol, the amazing Scott Savol

 

I am amazed that he and Federov lasted as long as they did... but, then, this is America!

[divad]

Yes, and if they did, they wouldn't post a mug like that as their avatar!

 

In case it's over your head, that's not me.... It's everybody's favorite American Idol, the amazing Scott Savol

 

I guess you have a long white beard and wear a yellow dress?

 

Over my head? No, but I don't have, or watch TV

 

As if this has any relevance to anything

 

But it DOES say a lot about you . . .

[Crackandpresstoan11]

But it DOES say a lot about you . . .

 

Yes it does. You found me out. I am so ashamed. Ok, I'll admit it, I OWN A TV, and sometimes I even watch it!!! There... are you happy now... how embarrassing for me.

 

I think more things are to be said of someone who does not own a TV. Very strange.

 

[divad]

But it DOES say a lot about you . . .

 

Yes it does. You found me out. I am so ashamed. Ok, I'll admit it, I OWN A TV, and sometimes I even watch it!!! There... are you happy now... how embarrassing for me.

 

I think more things are to be said of someone who does not own a TV. Very strange.

 

 

I think that is you

[Crackandpresstoan11]

You're just mad you couldn't get $2200 for your Conan mag. I told ya you were

[rube11]

How did we get from "grade my Flash" to American idol to a Conan magazine?

[burntboy]

How did we get from "grade my Flash" to American idol to a Conan magazine?

 

this is what happens when a couple of sensitive guys don't see eye-to-eye on an issue........original topic be Damned!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Fan4Fan]

How did we get from "grade my Flash" to American idol to a Conan magazine?

 

this is what happens when a couple of sensitive guys don't see eye-to-eye on an issue........original topic be Damned!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

 

[rube11]

Hey Tom,

 

Sent you a PM.

 

Rube

[Crackandpresstoan11]

I didn't get it

[FFB]

Based on your scans, I wouldn't have a problem w/ you calling those 8.5's. I break all of the CGC books I buy out of the slabs (regardless of grade) , so I get a better look at graded books than most people. I would say 75% of the time, DC's are graded more harshly than Marvels... and the older the book, the wider the difference ( in regards to silver, anyway).

 

The single, lower spine stress on the Superman book is too long for 8.5 IMO. That's probably what caused the 7.5, along with the other light peripheral wear. Agreed on the Wonder Woman though. Unless there's an internal defect or other defect on the back cover that I can't see, it looks undergraded.

[FFB]

Oh, and Steve, I think the book is a 9.2, maybe 9.4 if the corner is really sharp like you say. I don't think you will get a 9.6 with the slight wear to the spine tips, the light curl to the lower right corner, and the visible but light spine stress.

 

Whatever the structural grade though, the colors and whites are stunning. Great book!

[rube11]

Thanks FFB,

 

I will let you know when it comes back.

 

Tom,

 

Recent the PM.

[Crackandpresstoan11]

Reply sent!

[rube11]

Came back today 9.4!!!

[Aces]

9.4

 

 

I want four points!

[uclapeterg]

9.4

 

 

I want four points!

 

Ok.