2021 "THIS SET DOESN'T EXIST, PLEASE BUILD" REQUESTS
11 11

236 posts in this topic

Matt:

Please create a "Vampirella Facsimile Edition Complete With Variants" set:

Vampirella Facsimile Edition #1 (2073364015)

Vampirella Facsmile Edition #1 Blue Foil Edition (2094083008)

Vampirella Facsmile Edition #1 Red Foil Edition (2094083007)

Vampirella Facsmile Edition #1 Silver Foil Edition (2094083009)

Vampirella Facsimile Edition #2 (2103674006)

Vampirella Facsimile Edition #3 (3719911021)

Vampirella Facsimile Edition #30 (3719911016)

Thanks - Mike

CGC has only graded issues #1, 2, and 30. This is not eligible for a set. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Taxmick1 said:

Matt:

Please create a "Vampirella Facsimile Edition Complete With Variants" set:

Vampirella Facsimile Edition #1 (2073364015)

Vampirella Facsmile Edition #1 Blue Foil Edition (2094083008)

Vampirella Facsmile Edition #1 Red Foil Edition (2094083007)

Vampirella Facsmile Edition #1 Silver Foil Edition (2094083009)

Vampirella Facsimile Edition #2 (2103674006)

Vampirella Facsimile Edition #3 (3719911021)

Vampirella Facsimile Edition #30 (3719911016)

Thanks - Mike

CGC has only graded issues #1, 2, and 30. This is not eligible for a set. 

@Matt GMatt: I'm finding this a bit frustrating as we seem to be going around and around on these particular facsimile books ... what is the criteria for you to create a set? How many individual issues have to be graded?  I often see the comment that there is "not enough interest" to create a set, but what is the criteria?  How many total books have to be graded for you to deem it worthy to create a set?  Or am I missing something and there is some other way to create a set even if there are only 2 or 3 books or issues graded? Apologies for the rant - Mike   

Hi @Taxmick1,

I can understand your frustration and I apologize for any inconvenience. Please find the link to a thread below that is also pinned to the top of the CGC Registry section of the boards. There are many one-off scenarios and gray areas so this post will be updated as needed. I recently created the post in an effort to shed light on the process but this list does not cover every scenario and it may be changed as sets evolve.

One thing to note, the CGC registry is meant to be a fun and competitive atmosphere for everyone. When a collector requests a book that is not widely collected, we run the risk of limiting the participation within the community. For reference, when a user requests an esoteric foreign book (may be a reprint), that has a small mention of a character, into an Artist Cover set, CGC must decide if this addition is beneficial to one user or the community. While it may upset the requestor, we are keeping the set from being diluted and keeping the rest of the community happy. 

Thank you

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can you please add Fat Freddy's Cat (Complete With Variants) set that mirrors the existing Fat Freddy's Cat set.

 

To that set, can you please add the following as well:

Fat Freddy's Cat 1 UK 95p Variant 2079884001

Unfortunately, CGC has only graded #1 UK variant so this is not eligible for its own set. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can you please create a set for 

Wizard Mini-Comic 

TYVM

ScotchOnTheRocks We are looking into adding this set, please send any additional info such as cert numbers or photos if possible, thank you.

Set added 5/5/21. Please provide cert numbers for any additional issues you would like added.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please create an invincible complete with variants set that includes 

The following:

Invincible #1 Skybound 5th anniversary regular

Invincible #1 Skybound 5th anniversary sketch

Invincible #1 Skybound 5th anniversary blue sketch

Invincible Fcbd #1

Invincible local comic shop day #1

Invincible #1 red foil. 300 graded in census

Invincible #1 blue foil. 300 graded in census

Invincible #1 yellow foil. 300 graded in census

Thank you, Phillip

Hello @Phillip,

Thank you for your email. Upon further review, the Invincible set began in 2005 so it should default as a "Complete with Variants" set per the registry guidelines below. I have updated the set title and we will add the books listed in your request above. Thank you for your patience and I apologize for any confusion,

https://www.cgccomics.com/boards/topic/473777-cgc-registry-set-slot-guidelines/

Slots added 4/14/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Matt:

As discussed per DMs from April 9-13, please create a: "Dave Stevens Foreign Covers Complete" set:

All American Comics 1 Italian Edition (3733114008)

Comic Art #12 Italian Edition (3733114009)

Comic Art #58 Italian Edition (3733114010)

Comix Kiss Comix  #6 (2070196020)

Comix Kiss Comix #9 (2070196021)

Comic Kiss Comix #12 (2070196021)

Generation 4 #41 (French Edition) (2094083022)

Grandi Eroi 15 Italian Edition (2103674010)

Ilustracion + Comix Internacional #48 (Spanish Edition) (2101290022)

L'Eternauta Junior 1 Italian Edition (2070094001)

L'Eternauta Junior 2 Italian Edition (2070094002)

L'Eternauta Junior 3 Italian Edition (2070094003)

L'Eternauta Junior 4 Italian Edition (2070094004)

Rocketeer #NN Spanish Edition (2101290019)

Rocketeer: Le Avventure Complete #nn (2070096003)

Scarce #v2 #27 (2039495009)

Special U.S.A. #7 (2094083016)

Special U.S.A. #19 (2070197004)

Titanic 26 Dutch Edition (2101290011)

Titanic 35 (Dutch Edition) (2094083023)

USA Magazine 25 (2070197005)

USA Magazine 31 (2070197008)

USA Magazine 38 (2070197010)

USA Magazine 48/49 (2101290006)

USA Magazine 53 (2039495004)

USA Magazine 65 (France) (2101290010)

Zona 84 #86/88 Spanish Edition (3733114007)

Maxx #6 (3725846008) - This is a magazine size book from Sweden 

Comic Art #104 (3725846024) - This is a magazine size book from Italy

Comic Art #105 (3725846025) - This is a magazine size book from Italy

Comico Attractions #6 Italian Edition (3725846023) - This is a magazine size book from Italy

Comic Art #82 (3733114011) - This is a magazine size book from Italy

Comic Art #84 (3733114012 - This is a magazine size book from Italy

Comic Art #94 (3733114013) - This is a magazine size book from Italy

Comic Art #106 (3733114016) - This is a magazine size book from Italy

Comic Art #117 (3733114017) - This is a magazine size book from Italy

Thanks - Mike

Set added 4/28/21.

image.png

image.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 hours ago, Phillip said:

Please create an invincible complete with variants set that includes 

The following:

Invincible #1 Skybound 5th anniversary regular

Invincible #1 Skybound 5th anniversary sketch

Invincible #1 Skybound 5th anniversary blue sketch

Invincible Fcbd #1

Invincible local comic shop day #1

Invincible #1 red foil. 300 graded in census

Invincible #1 blue foil. 300 graded in census

Invincible #1 yellow foil. 300 graded in census

Thank you, Phillip

Hello @Phillip,

Thank you for your email. Upon further review, the Invincible set began in 2005 so it should default as a "Complete with Variants" set per the registry guidelines below. I have updated the set title and we will add the books listed in your request above. Thank you for your patience and I apologize for any confusion,

https://www.cgccomics.com/boards/topic/473777-cgc-registry-set-slot-guidelines/

Slots added 4/14/21.

Thank you very much

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Matt,

I notice that there exists a Competitive Set titled "Australian Edition (1971-75)".

Can you please ADD a Competitive Set titled "Australian Edition (1950 -70)", please?

I have a number of CGC Graded comics that would fit into this category, namely

Rin Tin Tin and Rusty CGC 0319936004 and 0319936005

Outer Space CGC 0319936006; 0350613004; 0325243005; 3794853003

Space Adventures CGC 0325243003

Note: Each of the above match the US versions "cover images" but may have different issue numbers.

 

The comics below have cover images that do not match any US versions:

Catman 18 different issues all CGC graded (incld CGC 2049587001; 2049587002; 1295463004 etc)

Flash Gordon 9 CGC graded issues

Thanks

Dikko

Hello @Dikko,

Thank you for your request. We reached out to our graders and looked into parameters for this set. Unfortunately, we are not able to fulfill your request. Every one of the certification numbers you provided is the only graded examples by CGC with the exception of Adventures of Catman #19 which CGC has graded 2 copies. Due to the low population data, we are not able to fulfill the request. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

HI THERE NEED THIS NEW SET "ULTIMATE ELEKTRA" 1-5

CAN YOU ADD MY BOOKS

ISSUE #1 CERT #3798790004

            #2 CERT #3798790006

            #3 CERT #3798790007

            #4 CERT #3798790008

            #5 CERT #3798790009

Set added 5/20/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Matt @Matt G

Would it be possible for you to create a set for RADIANT LOVE which encompasses issues 2 thru 6?

Published from Dec 1953 thru'  August 1954 by Gilmor Magazines (aka Stanley Morse)

Certification number  #  2105959001

Hope this is possible.

Many thanks

paul

Set added 5/20/21.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is there a Department of Truth set coming? Or did I miss it in the list (sometimes they are out of alphabetical order, so maybe I missed it)?

If not could we get one started:

Issue #1 cert 3777146023
Issue 1 3rd print Cert 3808569005
Issue 2 Cert 3787734007
#4 Cert 3810785006

 

Thanks!

Set added 5/20/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To whom it ay concern, can you please create

Chapel vol 2 set and Persuasion (by Ryan Kincaid) vol 1 set with variants

 

Thank you for your time

Hi @RayJr,

Unfortunately, CGC has only graded Chapel v2 #1 Quesada Variant Cover. In addition, CGC has only graded issues #1 and #5 from Volume 1. This is not eligible for a set creation at this time. Persuasion has many variants but only has 2 issues which makes it ineligible as well. From what I understand, issue #1 was published by the creator and issue #2 was published by Counterpoint but they are technically the same book. I apologize for any inconvenience.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Could you please build a set for the Valiant page and I'm not sure which would be a better title for it 

Bloodshot (1997) or Bloodshot v2 - We will create a set named Bloodshot Vol. 2 (1997)

Starting with Bloodshot Preview v2 #1

Reference #0257925003

Also include #s , v2 #1 through v2 #16

TYVM

Set added with all available issues 5/29/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/6/2021 at 8:31 PM, Enjoyhockey said:

Hi Matt, new to the process of requesting new series to be added.

I am requesting Sepulcher from Illustration Studios released in 2000 be added as a set.

I have all comics from this series graded.  I will understand if due to the obscurity of the title if CGC does not add as a series.

Hi @Enjoyhockey,

Thank you for your request. CGC has graded one copy of each of the 4 issues so this would be too obscure to warrant a set. This would look great as a custom set though!

Thanks for your patience and reviewing my request.

V/R

Eric

Thanks for the reply Matt, I appreciate it.

I do have it as a custom set.

V/R

Eric

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
11 11