2021 "THIS SCORE NEEDS FIXIN" REQUESTS
4 4

99 posts in this topic

Could you check Savage Sword of Conan mags - issues 4 to 15, maybe more, need fixing. Points have been the same for like 15 years or more. I'm paying like $4-7 per point - that's not fair :-)

A suggestion would be to raise #4-10 to at least 400 points, and #11-15 to 300 points. This compared to latest GPAnalysis prices. 

For example, I just paid $650 for #11 9.8 and got 120 points.  

Thank you :foryou:

Scores updated 5/12/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Matt,

    Here is a batch of grossly undervalued gold and silver age books that I would like to bring to your attention.

Out Of The Shadows # 8 - Standard Publ.   precode classic shrunken heads cover

GRADE     SALE       DATE         PTS

1.5            $420          12/2020        32

1.8              550            3/2021        35

4.0              990           6/2019         98

5.5            2450           8/2020        168

7.0            4400           2/2021        294   I purchased from a national dealer

 

Worlds Of Fear # 9 - Fawcett 1953    classic cover

GRADE      SALE       DATE        PTS

2.0              $660         10/2020       19

2.0                710         10/2020       19

2.5                832         10/2018       26

4.0              2600          3/2021        45

Very sought after and scarce issue right now.

 

Thing # 15 -  Charlton   classic Steve Ditko  precode horror issue

GRADE      SALE       DATE      PTS

3.0             $900         2/2019        105

4.0               960         2/2020        147

4.5             1200         8/2019        168

6.0             2100        11/2019       279

7.0             1701        12/2018      441

 

Marvel Tales #95 - Atlas   classic cover

GRADE       SALE       DATE      PTS

3.0              $675         6/2017       86

4.0               1175        8/2019       120

5.5               1140        7/2018       206

6.5               1850        6/2017      257

7.5               2400       11/2019     429

9.4             15000         8/2018     5148

Many of the Atlas horror titles are vastly undervalued.

 

Weird Tales Of The Future # 3 -  Aragon Publ.   classic Wolverton  precode cover

GRADE    SALE     DATE       PTS

3.5         $1700       5/2020      208

4.5           2855       8/2020      277

5.0           2600       1/2019      347

5.5           2950       11/2019    416

9.0         15422        3/2018     3465

 

Terrifying Tales #13  - Star Publ. classic LB Cole devil cover

GRADE     SALE      DATE       PTS

3.0           $365         12/2019     56

3.5            368          6/2019       68

5.0           1080         10/2020     113

5.5            960          11/2019     135

Highly sought after Cole issue

 

Terrors Of The Jungle #4 - Star Publ. classic LB Cole cover

GRADE   SALE     DATE      PTS

3.5          $238       9/2019      44

4.5           452        8/2020      58

6.5           925        9/2020      109

7.0           1195      5/2018      152

 

 

Terrors Of The Jungle # 7 - Star Publ. LB Cole cover

GRADE    SALE    DATE     PTS

4.5           $471      9/2019       79

5.0             650      2/2020       99

5.5             618      10/2018    119

6.0            1200     6/2019      132

 

Startling Terror Tales # 13 - Star publ. classic LB Cole cover

GRADE    SALE      DATE      PTS

4.0          $468        1/2020       48

5.0           627         3/2020       69

5.5           800         8/2020       83

6.0           900         12/2019     92

7.0         1300         7/2018      145

 

Authentic Police Cases #15 - St.John   classic Matt Baker cover

GRADE    SALES     DATE      PTS

4.5           $720         6/2019      62

5.0             660         11/2018     78

7.0             890         12/2019     163

8.0           2160         10/2020     326

 

Adventures Of Rex The Wonder Dog #4 - DC Comics   1st Detective Chimp

GRADE     SALES     DATE      PTS

5.0            $1885       8/2020      55

7.5              4560       3/2021     138

9.0              1130       10/2019    550

this issue has taken off lately. considered scarce.

 

Strange Adventures # 50 - DC Comics  classic robot cover

GRADE    SALES     DATE     PTS

  2.0          $250      11/2018      14

  3.5           465        8/2020       27

  6.5           750        11/2019     68

  8.0          2040       11/2019     189

  8.5         2640        12/2019    302

 

Silver Surfer #3 - Marvel    1st Mephisto app

GRADE    SALES     DATE      PTS

4.0            $450        3/2021     72

4.5             595         3/2021     82

6.5            1121        3/2021     154

8.0            1950        3/2021     431

8.5            2999        3/2021    687

9.0           4015         3/2021    1025

9.4           7995         2/2021    3075

9.6          15950        2/2021    5125      

9.8          38400        11/2020     8200

Smokin' hot book right now

 

Hot Stuff # 1 - Harvey

GRADE   SALES     DATE        PTS

3.0         $531          9/2020       50

4.0           675          2/2020       70

6.0          1434         6/2016       133

6.5          1096        1/2020        150

8.0          2800        5/2017        420

8.5          5079        8/2013        670

These key Harveys are long overdue for adjustments

 

Little Dot #1 - Harvey

GRADE    SALE      DATE       PTS

0.5          $400         10/2017      51

1.5           1500         6/2017       65

2.0          1983          4/2018       87

3.0         2500           9/2017      145

5.0         5000           3/2018      290

8.0         6573           5/2013     1218

9.2        21510         11/2014     4350

 

Richie Rich # 1 -  Harvey

GRADE    SALE     DATE    PTS

3.0           $800      12/2018     160

5.0           1400      12/2019     320

5.5           2220      8/2020       380

8.0          4080       2/2019       1302

8.5          7768       5/2012       2100

 Appreciate any time you can spend on these.

JT

Scores updated 5/14/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/11/2021 at 2:50 PM, RICK STARR said:

Hello Matt and Happy New Year to you and all your staff.

I am requesting some more updated scores for precode , esoteric and certain good girl art books that need serious consideration.

Scores updated on 3/31/21. Thank you

Jo Jo Comics (Fox Publ.) # 25   classic Matt Baker cover

PTS      GRADE     PRICE     DATE

25          3.0            $870        7/2020

30          3.5              679        11/2017

40          4.5             1515       10/2020

75          6.5             1673        2/2018

 

Manhunt # 14 (Magazine Enterprise)  classic hypodermic needle cover

PTS      GRADE       PRICE     DATE

11           0.5             $635          9/2020

61           5.0              2600         2/2020

73           5.5              2400         10/2017

 

Phantom Lady # 17 (Fox)    classic Matt Baker cover

PTS     GRADE     PRICE      DATE

525       0.5           $1956        5/2020

1200      2.5            4800        7/2020

2100     4.0             7800        4/2019

3600     5.5             9560        2/2018

4500     6.5            11000       7/2017

 

Teen-Age Romances # 32 (St John)  classic Matt Baker cover

PTS     GRADE      PRICE      DATE

33          2.5            $460         6/2020

41          3.0              960         9/2020

83         5.0               750         12/2015

173       7.0               837          7/2011

The 5.0 and 7.0 if sold today would far exceed these prices. This issue and others are just plain scarce.

Teen-Age Romances # 38 (St John) classic Matt Baker cover

PTS      GRADE      PRICE      DATE

80            3.0           $504          9/2018

112          4.0             463          10/2019

240          6.5             950          2/2014

672          8.0            1301         3/2013

Same as above for the 6.5 and 8.0 copies here, they would sell for far more today.

 

Teen-Age Romances # 43 (St John)    superb and scarce Matt Baker cover

PTS      GRADE     PRICE      DATE

26           2.0           $552         8/2018

44           3.0             845         10/2019

53           3.5             952           9/2019

 

Authentic Police Cases # 6 (St John)  Classic Baker cover and Seduction Of The Innocent issue

PTS    GRADE      PRICE     DATE

76         2.5           $636         10/2019

133       4.0             900          7/2020

475       7.5            2868         8/2017

798       8.0            1640         2/2014 

Authentic Police Cases # 8 and #10    (St John) both classic Baker covers

ISSUE    PTS      GRADE      PRICE      DATE

#8          78            5.0            $960         10/2019

#8          116          6.5              896          5/2014

#10        116          6.5              840           5/2020

#10        163          7.0              621          12/2020

These two issues are comparable in recent sales

 

Reform School Girl  (Avon)  scarce one-shot

PTS      GRADE       PRICE       DATE

495         1.5             $1475         7/2020

550         1.8               2150        12/2019

1100       3.0               2995         4/2020

1320        3.5             3090         1/2020

2640        5.5             5200         2/2015

3300        6.5             7986         3/2020

9240       8.0             20400        9/2020

 

A number of titles and issues with LB Cole covers are in extreme need of updates. I am listing some issues that have some relevant recent data.

Blue Bolt #105  (Star)

PTS    GRADE     PRICE     DATE

86         3.5           $2503       11/2019

115       4.5             3819         5/2020

360       7.5             6900         8/2018

605       8.0             2888         6/2017

needless to say, the 8.0 would sell for 5 figures today, very tough issue in any grade!

 

Blue Bolt # 108 (Star)

PTS    GRADE     PRICE      DATE

39          2.0           $ 375       4/2020

65          3.0             442        8/2020

131        5.0             655       10/2020

174        6.0            1009       3/2020

326        7.5            1440      11/2019

 

Blue Bolt # 110 (Star)

PTS     GRADE     PRICE     DATE

91          4.0           $930        10/2020

104        4.5           1150         7/2019

157        5.0           1320        10/2020

196       6.5            1800        11/2019

548       8.0             2716        2/2019

 

Blue Bolt # 111 (Star)

PTS     GRADE      PRICE       DATE

71         3.5             $685          3/2019

83         4.0              766           3/2020

158       6.0             1320          7/2020

249       7.0             2247          5/2019

796       8.5             4555          12/2019

 

Blue Bolt # 112  (Star)

PTS     GRADE      PRICE     DATE

104         3.5            $650       6/2020

173         5.0              840      12/2019

230         6.0            1860      5/2019

364         7.0            1560      1/2020

728         8.0            2880      10/2019

 

Blue Bolt # 113   (Star)

PTS      GRADE      PRICE     DATE

31          0.5               $200      7/2019

126        4.0                580       9/2019

180        5.0                800        10/2020

239        6.0               1016       4/2018

239        6.0               1560       3/2019

450        7.5               4560       10/2020

 

Blue Bolt # 115  (Star)

PTS     GRADE      PRICE     DATE

70         2.5            $1250         4/2020

144       4.5              2880        12/2019

180       5.0              1560         5/2020

239       6.0              1920         11/2019

378      7.0               3611         3/2019

8993    9.6              16730        11/2017

 

Journey Into Mystery # 6 (Atlas) classic Bill Everett "skeletal bridal' cover

PTS     GRADE     PRICE     DATE

72          2.5           $800        12/2020

108        3.5           1050        5/2020

126        4.0            900         12/2019

239        6.0           2250         4/2018

270        6.5           3705         8/2015

378        7.0           3639         10/2018

 

Voodoo # 1  (Farrell)

PTS     GRADE      PRICE     DATE

65          2.5           $293         12/2018

162        5.0            720          7/2019

243        6.5            666          12/2019

340        7.0            1500         11/2018

 

Thank you, Matt, for any time you can spend on these!!

 

 

 

Thank you, Matt for these updates!!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

X-men #49 in 7.0 worth only 36 points, but 6.5's selling for $400

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313&_nkw=x-men+49+cgc+&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=x-men+49+cgc+7.0&LH_Complete=1&rt=nc&LH_Sold=1

X-men #50 in 8.5 worth a cool 125 points but now sell for $500 in 8.0

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313&_nkw=x-men+50+cgc&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=x-men+49+cgc+&LH_Complete=1&rt=nc&LH_Sold=1

X-men 94 selling for more but worth 153 points in 5.5

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313&_nkw=x-men+94+cgc&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=x-men+50+cgc&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1

x-men #221 in 9.8 worth 208 points but is now a $400 book

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313&_nkw=x-men+221+cgc+9.8&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=x-men+94+cgc&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1

X-men #266 in 9.8 is 360 points but in 9.8 is $1000 or so book

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313&_nkw=x-men+266+cgc+9.8&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=x-men+221+cgc+9.8&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1

X-men #282 is up in price worth 20 points in 9.2 $400 book in 9.8

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313&_nkw=x-men+282+cgc+9.8&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=x-men+266+cgc+9.8&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1

werewolf by night #33 is a $250 book in 4.5 but in 9.0 worth 85 points, not too many sales, but check it out anyway :wishluck: 

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313&_nkw=werewolf+by+night+33+cgc&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=werewolf+by+night+33+cgc+9.0&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1

 

Ultimate fallout #4 in cgc 9.0 is a $800-900 book worth only 90 points

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2334524.m570.l1313&_nkw=ultimate+fallout+4+cgc+9.0&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&_osacat=0&_odkw=werewolf+by+night+33+cgc&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1

Some of these scores were updated per previous request the others were updated 5/15/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

....

I'm on my tablet so cant post liks to Ebay sold

But rest assured

Incredible hulk 180 is now a $1400 book in 5.5 and $3000 book in 8.5

Ih 181 is a $7000 book in 7.5, and $3000 book in 2.5,3.0, and 3.5

According ot gpa

Scores updated 5/15/21.

Screenshot_20210405-184843_Samsung Internet.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Matt, 

I’m requesting a point increase of Thor 342. I own one of the three 9.9’s. Thor 342 current point total is only 30 points. I’ve seen 9.8 moderns with more points than the 9.9 I have. Thank you If a point increase is possible.

Score updated 5/15/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Since Moon Knight is blowing up all over the place, pretty much all his books are seeing an increase - however I'll stick to my favourite of the bunch.

All six issues of Moon Knight (1985) have a 9.8 point score of 24 (or 26 if SS) and some of those need to be adjusted.

While the prices for issues #3-5 are not major ($30-$80, though they are higher than years prior) it is with issues #1, #2 and #6 that have had bigger price bumps. #1 consistently is hitting above $100 for the last year (with the last $110 sale actually have been low) and lower grade copies also going up in price, and #6 has had a boost due to the popularity of the cover art (#6 is the only issue of the mini-series with some Signature Series data on it though)

Scores updated 5/15/21.

802554691_ScreenShot2021-04-07at6_17_13PM.thumb.png.8f95d4c4a9eccce449709e86062d73c9.png

 

2145920257_ScreenShot2021-05-13at11_07_28PM.thumb.png.ff3792d39190d099d2380eeb2a9d697c.png

 

458848115_ScreenShot2021-04-07at6_17_39PM.thumb.png.67f2f43732d1a212c55016b127381f0f.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When you have a moment, please take a look at Amethyst Princess of Gem World Mini Series #1? There are currently 2 slabbed examples, but the score in the Registry is currently 0 points. My copy is 0164876030. Thanks for your time!

Score updated 5/15/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 HI Matt,

 

Can All Select Comics #7 be updated please? It should be 15,000 in 9.4, I think. Recent sales seem to back that up. Serial number: 1307824014

8.5 $7500 May 2020

5.0 $3225 Aug 2020

3.5 $2640 Nov 2020

As always, whatever you can do is appreciated!

Score updated 5/15/21.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hoping for a bump for Adventure Comics 300 (9/62).

CGC    12mo$      points

9.4      6600         300
9.2      3600         150
7.5       380           25
6.5       210           15
6.0       225           13
5.5       104           12
5.0       111           10

Thank You!

Score updated 5/15/21.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Greetings,

I'm hoping to have the Oblivion Song set scores updated to highlight keys and give the set depth. With a movie coming, Oblivion Song #1 variants have seen some modest price improvements.

The smallest point increase should be afforded to 'Oblivion Song #1' - CGC 9.8 sold for $75 April 18th 2021

'Oblivion Song #4 Secret Variant Cover' should recieve the same, small point increase (1:10) - no sales

'Oblivion Song #1 Pink Signature variant' should recieve slightly more than the standard cover (1:10) - CGC 9.8 sold for $115 April 18th 2021

'Oblivion Song #1 Collector's Edition' was limited to 1,000* produced, with conflicting reports on how many shipped, and was included in a box that retailed for $200 - CGC 9.8 sold for $335 April 16th 2021

'Oblivion Song #25 Campbell Sketch Cover' was limited to 350* produced - retailed for $65 "raw" or $250 for CGC 9.8 on JSCs website.

'Oblivion Song: Advance Edition nn' is the undisputed first appearance of Nathan Cole and many other great characters. Rare. - last CGC 9.8 sale for $375 July 2020. Should be the big point book of the set imo. 

My first request. Hopefully it qualifies and I didn't make too many mistakes. Thank you for the consideration! 

Scores were updated 6/1/21, except issue #4.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
4 4