RATE YOUR GA BOOKS ON COVER APPEAL ALONE. Forget grading criteria. 6 6

[Scrooge]

AA

BBB

CC

F

[PopKulture]

Not sure about the grading criteria, so I'll just go with a more traditional letter grading scale:

B+ for Donald

Edited May 19, 2021 by PopKulture

[PopKulture]

C for Bats - absurd, which is simultaneously half the charm, I know. 

[PopKulture]

D  I may be fond of these "educational" Four Colors, but I'm trying to be somewhat objective.

[PopKulture]

B is for Betty (and Veronica!)

[PopKulture]

A-   And top of this small class of books - simple, effective, well-rendered and colored. It could be a poster! 

[batman_fan]

On 5/17/2021 at 2:19 PM, GreatCaesarsGhost said:

AA

 

I would call this one an AAAA

The detail is amazing on it and although the woman's face is not fully visible because of the angle the feature appearance is very nice.

[batman_fan]

AA.  For me it is the peak of GA.  The large image of the hero taking on the bad guys.

[PopKulture]

16 minutes ago, batman_fan said:

AA.  For me it is the peak of GA.  The large image of the hero taking on the bad guys.

That's an A+ for me, or an AAA per the OP's criteria! IMHO, it belongs to a small handful of GA books that get the highest possible mark (think More Fun 54 and Superman 14).  

[Paul © ® ⚽️💙™]

7 hours ago, PopKulture said:

A-   And top of this small class of books - simple, effective, well-rendered and colored. It could be a poster! 

Love P-P-P-Porky Pig.

[Scrooge]

Let's do a Pig one -

AAA

AA

A

BBB

BB

B

CCC

CC

F

Edited May 19, 2021 by Scrooge

[Scrooge]

Let's try some Romance -

AAA

AA

A

BBB

BB

D

 

[Badger]

AAA

[Badger]

AA

B

AA

AAA

C

A

 

[PopKulture]

5 hours ago, Badger said:

AAA

Agree!! One of THE best!!  

[PopKulture]

5 hours ago, Badger said:

AA

B

AA

AAA

C

A

 

Every one a classic! You were a little tough on "Volcano Valley," but spot-on for "Sheriff of Bullet Valley!" 

I was actually going to post my ratty FC 199, but yours in MUCH purdier.  And lest we forget:

For me, AAA or A+. I don't see how it could be any better.

[GreatCaesarsGhost]

AAAAAAAA (for innuendo)

[Badger]

1 hour ago, PopKulture said:

Every one a classic! You were a little tough on "Volcano Valley," but spot-on for "Sheriff of Bullet Valley!" 

I was actually going to post my ratty FC 199, but yours in MUCH purdier.  And lest we forget:

For me, AAA or A+. I don't see how it could be any better.

I could actually post every Barks cover. I love them all!

[Scrooge]

1 hour ago, PopKulture said:

I was actually going to post my ratty FC 199, but yours in MUCH purdier.

Mine's ratty too but the cost was just right: $0

I would not rate it as high but I'll definitely agree with the grade on the Volcano Valley: C

[catman76]

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA