Got this in last week. I will say that in-hand, I agree with the grade. I know it's tough through the slab to really tell but I'm very happy. The CGC slab is so clear, no Newton Rings, that you can really see the full cover gloss and the color dripping inks. The scanner greatly magnified the marks on the cover. I can barely see them in real life. The people who bought books in 9.4 and higher are hopefully blown away with their purchases. At the price point these are going for this will probably