2022 "THIS SCORE NEEDS FIXIN" REQUESTS"
3 3

82 posts in this topic

not sure about the 9.8's

but Iron man #55 in cgc 4.5 -6.5 selling for $600

and 7.0-8.0 selling for $1050-1250

which is a rise of about $500 in all grades

Adjusted Score according to recent sales data for 8.5 - 2/23/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_nkw=amazing+spiderman+16+cgc+&_sacat=0&LH_TitleDesc=0&LH_Complete=1&LH_Sold=1&_sop=16

this 9.8 might be new for ASM #16 at $20,000

Still 1.8, which I own lol now selling for $300, more power to those ahead of me :headbang: 

Adjusted score according to recent sales data for 7.0 - 2/23/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ASM #18 might be worth looking into.

5.0's now selling for $5-600 rather than $2-300

Higher grades even more :shy: 

Thank you for your consideration :) 

 

Adjusted scores according to recent sales for 9.8 on GP Analysis.  3/9/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Brian,

I was looking at the values of various books and some I think need adjustment:

Milo Manara Covers

Amazing X men 1  reg 3994967002 manara variant current points 24 last sale $275

Guardians of the Galaxy 5   reg 1991681016 manara variant current points 25 last sale $265

Thor God of Thunder 25 reg 3854718001 manara variant current points  25 last sale $300

x men 1 reg 0318526004 manara variant current points 24 last sale $199

x women 1 reg 3754266013 current points 24 last sale $140

Avenges World 1 reg 1038355006 manara variant current points 32  last sale $120

Daredevil Volume 2

Daredevil 9 reg 3705225021 current point 107  Go collect FMV $500

Daredevil 10 reg 3904963004   current point 25 go collect fmv $325

Gabriele Dell Otto covers

Harley Quinn 1 Bulletproof pink reg 1215433005 current points 24 FMV $190

vengeance 1 reg 2069817001 current points 427 FMV  $1300

The immortal iron fist 1 2nd printing reg 2089250011 current points 64   FMV $475

Secret war 2 reg 0278027020  current points 35 FMV 280

Marvel comics 1000 current points 80  FMV $180

 

There are some set that may deserve overhaul's but have focused on individual comics with big differences

 

Many Thanks

Robert

Bill Sienkiewicz covers

Fantastic four 1 reg 1962890005   current points 35 FMV 250

Elektra Assassin 2 reg 2003304010 current points 48 FMV $260

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Amazing X men 1  reg 3994967002 manara variant current points 24 last sale $275     Adjusted according to 2020 sales data
       
Guardians of the Galaxy 5   reg 1991681016 manara variant current points 25 last sale $265     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
Thor God of Thunder 25 reg 3854718001 manara variant current points  25 last sale $300     Adjusted according to 2021 sales data
       
x men 1 reg 0318526004 manara variant current points 24 last sale $199     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
x women 1 reg 3754266013 current points 24 last sale $140     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
Avenges World 1 reg 1038355006 manara variant current points 32  last sale $120     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
Daredevil 9 reg 3705225021 current point 107  Go collect FMV $500     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
Daredevil 10 reg 3904963004   current point 25 go collect fmv $325     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
Harley Quinn 1 Bulletproof pink reg 1215433005 current points 24 FMV $190     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
vengeance 1 reg 2069817001 current points 427 FMV  $1300     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
The immortal iron fist 1 2nd printing reg 2089250011 current points 64   FMV $475     Insufficient sales data
       
Secret war 2 reg 0278027020  current points 35 FMV 280     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
Marvel comics 1000 current points 80  FMV $180     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
Fantastic four 1 reg 1962890005   current points 35 FMV 250     Adjusted 9.8 UNI
       
Elektra Assassin 2 reg 2003304010 current points 48 FMV $260     Adjusted 9.8 UNI

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello Brian,

 The PCH and GGA market is still exploding and would like to bring to your attention a few iconic books that need some serious adjustments.

Startling Terror Tales #11 (Star Pub.) classic LB Cole cvr.

GRADE      SALE       DATE       CURRENT PTS.

  2.0           $1750       5/2021       620

  2.5           $1517       2/2021       827

  4.0           $4800       5/2021       1447

  5.0           $4560       2/2021        2068

  7.0          $18000      11/21          4342

  8.5          $19200      11/21          13853

 

Amazing Ghost Stories #14 (St John)   Terrific Matt  Baker horror cover

GRADE       SALE         DATE         CURRENT PTS.

  3.0              $690            11/2020          281

  3.5             $1680           11/2021          338

 5.5             $2100            5/2019           675

 6.0             $3000            4/2021           748

 8.5             $7200            9/2018           3769

9.2             $25200          1/2022            8438

 

World's Of Fear #9  (Fawcett)  classic cover ( very difficult to find in any grade)

GRADE     SALE      DATE        CURRENT PTS

2.0             $660          10/2020       129

2.5             $832          10/2018       171

3.5             $1825        6/2021         257

4.0             $2600        3/2021         300

4.5             $2400        11/2021       343

 

Weird Mysteries #5  (Gilmore) classic cover

GRADE        SALE        DATE         CURRENT PTS

0.5              $930             3/2018          656

1.5            $5520            2/2022           844

3.0            $4692            6/2021          1875

3.5           $5040             6/2021          2250

4.5           $6800             5/2020         3000

6.0           $11650           12/2019        4988

7.5          $15600            8/2019         9375   (This copy today would undoubtingly sell for much more)

 

Haunted Thrills #5  (Farrell) classic skull cover - finally starting to get some current data on this hot book

GRADE        SALE         DATE        CURRENT PTS

1.8               $1800         11/2021         134

3.0               $3600         1/2022           268

4.5               $4920         6/2021           429

 

Haunted Thrills # 6  (Farrell) classic skull cover - another issue finally getting some current data

GRADE        SALE         DATE          CURRENT PTS

3.0               $3012         1/2022           33  !!!!!!!!

4.0               $3414         2/2022          46

6.0               $3128        1/2021           88

6.5               $3300        11/2021         99

9.0              $10200       11/2021         660

 

Adventures Of Rex The Wonder Dog #4  (DC)  1st Detective Chimp

GRADE       SALE         DATE         CURRENT PTS

4.0             $2400          1/2022           175

5.0             $1885          8/2020           250

7.0             $4500         10/2021          525

7.5             $4560         3/2021            625

 

Seven Seas #4  (1947)   classic  Matt Baker cover

GRADE       SALE        DATE        CURRENT PTS

3.0              $5877        6/2021         2425

3.5              $7800        2/2021         2910

4.5              $9900        8/2019         3880

6.5             $13200       3/2018         7275

6.5             $18750       2/2022         7275

 

Seven Seas #6  (1947)   classic Matt Baker cover

GRADE       SALE        DATE        CURRENT PTS

2.5             $1784          1/2022          495

4.5             $2750          3/2018          990

6.0            $6000           8/2021          1647

6.5            $5040           4/2021          1857

7.5            $15600         6/2021          3095

 

Thanks, appreciate any of your time

JT

 

Scores adjusted per request. 3/14/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Because it's not appropriate to ask for updates to an entire set, I'll stick to a single issue of Marvel Mystery Comics.

Marvel Mystery Comics #4

Registry points in 1.5 (585) - Registry points in 3.5 (1560) - Registry points in 7.5 (6500)

Recent sale in 1.5 ($21600) - Recent sale in 3.5 ($26138) - Recent sale in 7.5 ($160000)

MyComicShop current ask for 4.0 ($45000) 

Thanks, and have fun with the GA prices and point values in general.

 

Adjusted score 3/15/22

 

MM4Evidence1.png

MM4Evidence2.png

MM4Evidence4.png

MM4Evidence5.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi 

For score upgrade consideration:

X-Men129 in CGC 9.8 = 1200 points.

the last 3 eBay sales + the last ComicLink sale in that grade ranged from $4500-$7000.

X-Men 137 in CGC 9.9 = 680 points.

There are 6 copies in this highest grade. These are CGC 9.9 sales, which have increased since 2013 (can show screenshots of all, if needed):

June, 2013: $1,989 (ComicLink Auction)

November, 2017: $3,107 (GPA)

February, 2022: $7,945 (ComicLink Auction)

 

Thanks

 

#129 adjusted

#137 adjusted according to sales for 9.8 in GP Analysis.  I did not adjust for 9.9, this would throw off the scores for the other grades.  I will talk to my colleagues about this issue on Friday, and make a determination then.

Thanks!

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Brian,

Can you take a look at Batman 121? It's a wee bit off currently. Thanks!

Batman #121 Universal 24 27 30 34 41 54 68 81 95 108 135 162 180 203 284 338 567 905 1350 2025 4050 6750 10800 13500 20250
    Rating   2020 Avg 2021 Avg 12m Avg 90Day Avg Last sale    
  UNI 9.4  
--
--
--
--
$80000Nov 2018
   
  UNI 9.2  
--
--
--
--
$7000Jun 2009
   
  UNI 9.0  
$202173
$222001
--
--
$22200Jan 2021
   
  UNI 8.5  
$185001
--
--
--
$18500Jul 2020
   
  UNI 8.0  
--
--
--
--
$15706Mar 2018
   
  UNI 7.5  
--
$87001
$87001
$87001
$8700Dec 2021
   
  UNI 7.0  
$43863
$78634
$78634
--
$6000Nov 2021
   
  UNI 7.0 Signed by Sheldon Moldoff
--
--
--
--
$1376Sep 2013
   
  UNI 6.5  
$35504
$43491
$49352
$55201
$5520Jan 2022
   
  UNI 6.5 John G. Fantucchio
$38061
$42822
$42822
$42131
$4213Dec 2021
   
  UNI 6.0  
$27257
$40576
$40576
--
$3605Dec 2021
   
  UNI 6.0 John G. Fantucchio
--
--
--
--
$3570Mar 2019
   
  UNI 5.5  
$23224
$34113
$34113
--
$3800Jun 2021
   
  UNI 5.5 Savannah Pedigree
--
--
--
--
$263May 2011
   
  UNI 5.0  
$24002
$27564
$30083
--
$3500Sep 2021
   
  UNI 4.5  
$17319
$25484
$26143
--
$2800Oct 2021
   
  UNI 4.0  
$13714
$19532
$21001
--
$2100Jul 2021
   
  UNI 3.5  
$14668
$18099
$18988
$19201
$1920Jan 2022
   
  UNI 3.5 CGC case cracked
$10271
--
--
--
$1027May 2020
   
  UNI 3.0  
$10925
$17729
$17729
$18131
$1813Dec 2021
   
  UNI 3.0 CGC case cracked
--
$13431
$13431
--
$1343Sep 2021
   
  UNI 2.5  
$10854
--
--
--
$1175Oct 2020
   
  UNI 2.5 Big Apple
--
--
--
--
$926Mar 2015
   
  UNI 2.0  
$10187
$12076
$12985
$12601
$1260Feb 2022
   
  UNI 1.8  
$9001
$11272
$11272
--
$1133Aug 2021
   
  UNI 1.5  
$7501
$9593
$10254
$12251
$1225Jan 2022
   
  UNI 1.0  
$8001
$9854
$9854
$11951
$1195Dec 2021
   
  UNI 0.5  
--
--
--
--
$405Oct 2017
   
  UNI 0.5 Incomplete
$3521
$7811
$7811
--
$781Oct 2021
   
  UNI 0.5 NO GRADE / 12th Page Only
--
$1001
$1001
--
$100Dec 2021
   
  UNI 0.5 NO GRADE / Coverless
$3001
--
--
--
$300Aug 2020
   

 

Score adjusted per request. 3/15/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello Brian,

I would like to request a score up date for the following books:

Aliens 1 second, third, fourth, fifth prints; current score for each is 24 points.  I am requesting the score be increased to 100 points each.  Current sales for fourth and fifth prints are $200 for a fourth print and over $1000 for a fifth print.  

Aliens 2 second, third, fourth print; current score for each is 24 points.  I am requesting the score be increase to 60 points each.  Current sales for third and fourth print are $206 for a third print and $500 for a fourth print.

Aliens 3 second and third print; current score for each is 24 points.  I am requesting the score be increased to 40 points each.  Current sale for a second print is $275.

Thank you for your consideration.

 

Scores Adjusted per request 3/15/22

76A8793E-0B3F-40F1-A212-0879F69D2F6D.png

1F13192C-5B45-43F8-9D6E-01FDDF375080.png

4694AE09-F241-4FED-BF05-5F5130C937D4.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Brian,

Please consider a score review for these books as well:

Aliens V2 #1 first and second prints; current score  is 24 points each.  I am requesting a score of 40 points each.  90 day average is $142.

Aliens V2 #2-4; current score is 24 points each.  I am requesting a score of 40 points each.  Current sales are $80-150 per book.

Aliens V2 #4 Celebrity Authentics edition; current score is 24 points.  I am requesting a score of 60 points.  Sales are $225-290.

My apologies for two separate posts.  

 

Scores adjusted per request - 3/15/22

Thanks for providing your point requests, makes it a lot easier!

 

97DB7AC5-1B2A-42E9-916A-C8BB85040A42.png

63664E7E-3D97-422A-BAB8-F0C2B95079BC.png

EB6C8494-0ACF-4BF0-89D7-12B875058319.png

B4E3CD40-F268-40E3-AC54-7D8EA5D04092.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Brian,

Please consider a score change for the following book:

 

Marvel Preview 2 (First origin of the Punisher)

Current points for this book are 880.  I would like to request this be changed to 2200.  

This book has dramatically increased in value over the past year and some change. 

12 month average is $3485

90 Day average is $4224 

last sale was $6000

 

For reference; Marvel Preview 4 (First appearance of Star Lord), Registry points 1600

12 month average $2537

90 day average $2490

last sale $2880

 

Thank you for your time.

Regards,

John

 

 

Score adjusted per request 3/22/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hi 

so for Sports ILLustrated vol-1-90

all issues 1-45 with a grade of 7.0 or higher should have at lest a score of 5 points not 1 because of their age(issues with an athlete in football, baseball ,basketball or hockey should get 10 points) 

thanks 

bobby

 

Hello @Bobbyp29

I do not have easy access to the cover images for books in the registry.  I have to dig quite a bit to find one image.  If you can provide a list of FMVs for the issues in question, I would be more than happy to adjust the scores.

Would you like the first 45 issues in the set adjusted?  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here's another single issue of Marvel Mystery Comics.

Marvel Mystery Comics #31

Registry points in 3.0 (163) - Registry points in 4.0 (228) - Registry points in 4.5 (260)

Recent sale in 3.0 ($3473) - Recent sale in 4.0 ($3600) - Recent sale in 4.5 ($5280)

ComicLink current ask for 6.5 ($8500)

Thanks as always for the housekeeping!

Screen Shot 2022-03-22 at 13.23.41.png

Screen Shot 2022-03-22 at 15.57.47.png

Screen Shot 2022-03-22 at 16.08.48.png

 

Score adjusted 5/26/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello Brian,

Please consider a score change for the following books:

 

Punisher Limited Series 1

12 month average: $1133

90 day average: $1514

Last sale: $1695

Current points are 160.  I am requesting that the score be changed to 700.  GPA does not distinguish wether the book was a direct or newsstand edition when sold.  This book is comparative to Wolverine Mini Series 1 (both Direct/Newsstand; see below).

For reference; Wolverine Mini Series 1, current Registry points 720

Direct Editions:

12 month average: $925

90 day average: $896

Last sale: $995

Newsstand:

12 month average: $1419

90 day average: $1401

Last sale: $1494

 

Punisher Limited Series 2

12 month average: $196

90 day average: $202

Last sale: $200

Current points are 80.  I am requesting that the score be changed to 200.

For reference; Wolverine Mini Series 2, current registry points 480.

12 month average: $530

90 day average: $527

Last sale: $487

 

Punisher Limited Series 3

12 month average: $190

90 day average: $245

Last sale: $221

Current points are 80.  I am requesting that the score be changed to 200.

For reference; Wolverine Mini Series 3, current registry points 480.

12 month average: $503

90 day average: $570

Last sale: $605

 

Punisher Limited Series 4

12 month average: $138

90 day average: $175

Last sale: $123

Current points are 80.  I am requesting that the score be changed to 200.

For reference; Wolverine Mini Series 4, current registry points 480.

12 month average: $319

90 day average: $335

Last sale: $335

 

Punisher Limited Series 5

12 month average: $193

90 day average: $219

Last sale: $206

Current points are 80.  I am requesting that the score be changed to 200.

 

Thank you for the consideration.

Regards,

John

Scores adjusted per request 5/25/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We should probably sorely adjust, Darth Vader #3 1st Aphra, from 2015

If 9.8 is selling for $500, and is only 24 points.

And 9.6 is selling for $250 and is only 15 points 
:wishluck: 

I would think it would be comparable to Thanos #13 from 2017, which 9.6 is 125 points, and 9.8 is 200, they sell for comparable amounts, I know 9.6 Thanos is $200

 

Score adjusted per request 5/26/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please adjust registry points for Detective Comics 29 (1939) - A true classic featuring Batman's second ever cover appearance and introduction to Dr. Death.

This has been an unusual year with already 2 Universal copies offered at auction. Quite frankly, I'll be shocked to see a 3rd Universal copy publicly offered this year. It would set a record lol

 

Results: (Both sales in March)

ComicLink 4.5 $110,000 worth 61667 points

ComicLink 2.5 $76,100 worth 30833 points

 

There is a Restored copy that will come to auction ( ComicLink in May ) but restored books are not a proper measure of a comic's current market value IMO.

Thank you for a good job.

Cheers.

Score adjusted per request 5/26/22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Brian

I'd like to request a few more reviews for Silver and Bronze books where Registry points have slipped behind current market trends.

For convenience I've used the 9.4 grade as an indicator of market trends for specific books in order to compare current registry points with latest reported GPA sales prices as per the table below.

Thanks for considering.

Title # Significance of Book Current Registry Points for Universal 9.4 grade Most recent GPA for Universal 9.4 grade ($)
         
Amazing Spider-man 58 Second appearance of Spider-Slayer 480 1000
Amazing Spider-man 59 First Mary Jane cover 645 1175
Amazing Spider-man 113 Doctor Octopus appears 220 542
Amazing Spider-man 121 Death of Gwen Stacy 975 1600
Amazing Spider-man 122 Death of Green Goblin 600 1276
Amazing Spider-man 124 First appearance of Man-Wolf 430 1320
Avengers 6 First appearance of Zemo and Masters of Evil 3000 4850
Avengers 23 First appearance of Ravonna Renslayer 450 2495
Daredevil 2 Second appearance of Daredevil 4800 11251
Daredevil 37 Daredevil vs. Doctor Doom 255 1250
Daredevil 43 Daredevil vs. Captain America 300 900
Daredevil 66 Trapped in the Tar Pits of Death 120 276
Daredevil 82 Daredevil vs. Scorpion 90 166
Doctor Strange (1968) 175 Sons of Satannish appearance 195 445
Fantastic Four 55 Thing vs. Silver Surfer 1200 1975
Fantastic Four 90 The Skrull takes a Slave 300 576
Fantastic Four 101 Maggia story 240 504
Fantastic Four 112 Hulk vs. Thing 1400 2280
Fantasy Masterpieces (1966) 1 Marvel fantasy reprints begin 270 660
Sub-Mariner (1968) 29 Sub-Mariner vs. Hercules 90 144
Tales of Suspense 55 Third appearance of Mandarin 1200 1951
Tales of Suspense 73 Iron Man vs. Black Knight 330 721
Tales of Suspense 76 First appearance of Ultimo 330 525
Tales of Suspense 97 First appearance of Whiplash 300 575
Tales of Suspense 98 Captain America vs. Black Panther 300 535
Thor 161 Galactus vs. Ego battle concludes 150 275
X-Men 6 Sub-Mariner vs. X-Men 3900 9088
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Administrator

Hello Everyone, 
Just a reminder that we are in the preliminary phase of choosing winners for the 2022 Registry Awards. 


Here is the official announcement: 


https://www.cgccomics.com/news/article/9908/


Note that the deadline is 5:00 pm on July 1st, 2022. 
After 5 pm, we will be freezing the registry, which means there will be no changes to the registry or requests fulfilled until July 30th 2022. 


There is an active thread on the boards concerning the Awards here: 

 


Please use this thread to nominate your favorite sets for the awards. 
  
Thanks! 
-Brian
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
3 3