PGM Daredevil #16 - Grade is in!
3 3

14 posts in this topic

Not the biggest fan of Daredevil but I am a Spidey fan. This issue is John Romita Sr’s first work on Spider-Man and I’ve always like the cover.

 

The bottom staple is giving me the most trouble with my own grading. It’s partially detached, in that it’s detached from the front cover but still attached to the back cover (is there a term for this?). I think I will send this comic in, but I am a little concerned the bottom staple could become fully detached during handling by CGC.

Anyway over to you guys, what grade do you think this is?

 

Thanks in advance!

2EB77D66-AB6E-44EC-ABEA-6F7E079D5E47.jpeg

88BEC9B7-EB2F-4F89-8951-806E629647D5.jpeg

293C1F76-165D-4261-9969-9062F1040C77.jpeg

F562E831-A9A4-4E9C-AC91-2B74F96A3C1F.jpeg

6DDC8B32-AAF5-407B-A513-E8AAA20C4F84.jpeg

C3D5A35B-2857-4B50-9CA2-075F73A6572D.jpeg

2C96BF02-7C5C-43BC-B875-D7E2F23710D5.jpeg

E32F41E0-0EA9-4CD7-BB14-DAC8F354A678.jpeg

2EBB1C83-424A-4EF5-9912-30E7FCEA9220.jpeg

612C7DC4-9678-4C5A-897B-30331C97F2A1.jpeg

0E9407EC-F3E5-474E-948B-E93A8CC59DBA.jpeg

BCC367A4-567F-46DB-B5EE-3510B8222B56.jpeg

5A88A5AD-90A0-42A6-802F-2746D9A5A829.jpeg

E272533A-BE31-40B7-87C1-EBCE560C1FB3.jpeg

5EDF4E93-F690-4AEC-AD4A-75B07397616E.jpeg

Edited by Deutero
Grade is in
Link to comment
Share on other sites

@grendelbo

@Bayowolf

What do you guys think it would be if the bottom staple was fully detached? I’m pretty sure my Batman #171 had a partially detached staple when I sent it in, but the grader’s notes had it is fully detached. As such I think there’s a fairly strong chance of it becoming fully detached when I send it in.

 

Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/17/2022 at 5:10 AM, Deutero said:

@grendelbo

@Bayowolf

What do you guys think it would be if the bottom staple was fully detached? I’m pretty sure my Batman #171 had a partially detached staple when I sent it in, but the grader’s notes had it is fully detached. As such I think there’s a fairly strong chance of it becoming fully detached when I send it in.

 

Thanks

A grade lower than my previous estimate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/30/2022 at 2:02 PM, Deutero said:

@LowGradeBronze@grendelbo@Bayowolf@Mmanick@Galen130

 

Grade is in!

 

6.5 Off-White to White

 

Notes:

staple detached left bottom of front cover
light creasing to cover
light staining to cover

 

Very pleased with this one!

That an awesome grade for you was just surprised it was graded that high with a deatched staple. Congrats and cool book 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
3 3