PGM ASM 361
3 3

6 posts in this topic

Hey everyone!

Could you please help me figure out what the grade for this would be? 

Defects I can see:

-Very tiny non color breaking ticks. 

-Blue ink mark above the signature (Went to my LCS and the owner pulled out his copy and it has the same smudge. He concluded it was probably a printer error. But who knows 🤷‍♂️)

-On the back bottom, there is a small nick on the red box that says NEW FROM

-Middle of the back cover. Not sure it would be considered a color breaking tick or not but the tick is there

-Bottom back cover. Small non color breaking ticks

The inside pages are flawless

Please tell me this can be at least a 9.2 lol. I feel like that nick alone gets it to 9.2. Add the rest and it may be lower. 😩

This is my beautiful baby boy that’s come with me throughout my life. Hoping for the best.

I appreciate the feed back from everyone.

Have a great day!

556F575D-CBD5-42AB-B9BA-D956714A55A1.thumb.jpeg.dfba57ed005a0ac56f6d03fc0c7d482f.jpeg

EB4D6E2F-F8AE-4AD7-AD53-7038E0868A17.thumb.jpeg.5e780f0dbca31d56612897a4998630b6.jpeg9B17A7F5-AC89-4E1C-B632-94DA644E6ED7.thumb.jpeg.e98b55f8338021f3606b89acdb287335.jpegADB37B57-5D79-4802-8B61-036B65DB41B9.thumb.jpeg.9b8c61311836da65049017369b9ae50f.jpegBFE869F4-E004-4F61-869C-40E3E07F3DDB.thumb.jpeg.f95597f13af24502c16300cbb50d44cf.jpegB9BEF583-78C7-47A3-966E-8743F81E1477.thumb.jpeg.de5ac041391965a84298c062f36a8f35.jpegA6CA0E2C-6D74-4E2F-AE46-474630C126BB.thumb.jpeg.610edd39b6b58ee623c892ae84d423cd.jpeg6599BDD0-43DF-4598-A9E3-23C74218AF05.thumb.jpeg.b56a0f43624ddfb690ae825059115ddf.jpegFE1DC5A0-9506-44E1-8669-5CD0D03CDD3C.thumb.jpeg.6051d61a5c69f7656ceaa68258175c11.jpeg165B6957-4E28-43D9-8298-DEC3CF8EDAE8.thumb.jpeg.18c9cdbc6f1b9678f9f1e29de6602e8b.jpegC833D884-2BC3-4F88-AFEA-D9E739E382BB.thumb.jpeg.8e974738bc4cd9650a67c06fe1f53f51.jpegBB5C0B16-5157-4F9B-B743-9E424269C903.thumb.jpeg.9dfa18bcff40f9468ad0a24b9f156755.jpeg86F6C867-A813-4762-94D4-7472E1BF8337.thumb.jpeg.ec4e8a43f27af25af1339d02db522830.jpegF6B76A78-B1E5-4240-9E12-5504335551B7.thumb.jpeg.70473cff531d52f3a8740cda8468053a.jpeg51ECBA9D-B7C3-4A1F-ACBE-7296E4E98FB1.thumb.jpeg.69fadda6d19f8fe5c163aef859f41e3a.jpeg99596C05-2E3D-4D90-B6A0-A3F7161BAB5D.thumb.jpeg.d0aa9c68d35fd728f0cacef5c9249886.jpeg29BA69C7-7E85-447D-85CA-BE8021A56F32.thumb.jpeg.72d206475ac7cdc367f436b8c3d59f5d.jpegDC5A979E-EC4F-4CCB-8D0C-9AAFD1714220.thumb.jpeg.444a1962f4f1104bfd88dfae17a4367b.jpeg6946656C-5F2F-4FCE-8055-081B80406548.thumb.jpeg.28dfa7b84f6481d8050081a7123ad49c.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/16/2022 at 1:41 PM, timfinz said:

9.4 w/clean and press 9.6

The stain is a factory defect, and the small bindery tear in the red square on the back cover is also a factory defect, neither of these should effect the grade. Nice book

1496261590_ASM361wStainCGC9.8.thumb.jpeg.1037727dedfe941c32255286c5ea0ff0.jpeg

9.4

My copy doesn't have this blue smudge but this issue is full of manufacturing defects. Your copy seems to have avoided the gripper holes in the bottom of the front cover.

Thanks for posting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
3 3