PGM Atom #35

[RickHigh]

This is one of my favorite Gil Kane Atom covers, and he did some nice ones!! This is a beauty, and I'm hoping for a 9.4 (or course, I think ALL my books are 9.4's). The covers are clean and super glossy. The pages are snow white. This is just a gorgeous book. What do you think?

 

[october]

That whole series is way underrated. Some great covers in that run.

[RickHigh]

You know, it's amazing how a scan can bring out the tinest imprefections on a book. Just saw a small spine stress on the BLC that I hadn't noticed before.

[KingOfRulers]

Your other books are definetly 9.4 quality...but not this one.

 

This book is a 9.0.

[Sal]

That whole series is way underrated. Some great covers in that run.

 

jeebus. shut UP already.

 

this series is a DOG, people. total and utter chrap from start to finish. and the covers are uniformly poopy, despite what you may have heard to the contrary.

 

 

i think this particular slice of utter terribleness that people should hold off on attempting to start runs on until at least sometime in mid 2008 is

 

9.0

 

 

nice book, Rick.

[RickHigh]

Hey, Sal. I can't believe you haven't commented on my Cave Carson!! What an awesome series.

[marvelcollector]

That LLFC crease really hurts...keeps ot out of 9.2 or higher....9.0

[divad]

This is a beauty, and I'm hoping for a 9.4 (or course, I think ALL my books are 9.4's). The covers are clean and super glossy. The pages are snow white. This is just a gorgeous book. What do you think?

 

I think you will be disappointed Impact creases are graded much harsher than a even a normal crease, as they generally affect the whole corner. I think you're looking at no higher than a 8.5 . . .

 

 

btw, I agree with Sal . . . The Atom is an also-ran

[RickHigh]

 

btw, I agree with Sal . . . The Atom is an also-ran

 

Pleeeeease...Sal doesn't have a clue. Not only does he not like The Atom, but he doesn't like Cave Carson!!! And, he doesn't like the cover of Cap #110

 

I mean, what does he know.

[B-Smooth]

This is a beauty, and I'm hoping for a 9.4 (or course, I think ALL my books are 9.4's). The covers are clean and super glossy. The pages are snow white. This is just a gorgeous book. What do you think?

 

I think you will be disappointed Impact creases are graded much harsher than a even a normal crease, as they generally affect the whole corner. I think you're looking at no higher than a 8.5 . . .

 

 

btw, I agree with Sal . . . The Atom is an also-ran

 

agreed. 8.5 at best due to the crease in the bottom left corner. CGC will kill it. Still, an ImPRESSive book.