PGM Marvel Spotlight #2

[wasonff]

 

[KingOfRulers]

6.0

[-cryptkeeper-]

5.5

[october]

6.5/7.0

[joeypost]

6.0 assuming there are no issues with the spine( looks like there may be splits) if thats the case then a 5.0.

[divad]

6.5/7.0

 

Absolutely Not a bad looking copy

[wasonff]

6.0 assuming there are no issues with the spine( looks like there may be splits) if thats the case then a 5.0.

 

No spine splits but some wear on the top and bottom of the spine to be sure. Indentations on the cover from the staples as is common with this book.

[WA-migration]

Unfortunately, its probably around a 4 because of the writing on the upper left corner

[october]

See what I mean?

[marvelcollector]

6.5...despite 3 of the 4 corners being sub-par for a 6.0...the rest of the book is in the FN/VF range...

[Stout1a]

A nice book. 6.5 IMHO I forgot the square bound grade up...

[weaponx]

Looks like a 6.5

[inconceivable]

FN/VF 7.0 because of wear at corners and spine stress.

 

Dan

[Pirate]

6.0 even with the writing

[october]

Well, I just bought the book so I will get to see what it looks like in-hand.

[Steeler Nick]

anyone who says lower than 6.0 is being too harsh. all of the books flaws are allowed in FN grades

 

the fact that there are very few notable creases on that spine is impressive

[Point Five]

An easy 6.5 IMO, possible 7.0... but for what it's worth, I do think it's harder to grade squarebounds. If the bottom of the spine area didn't have that "wobbly" look from the glue, I suspect most people here would be giving the book .5-1.0 higher.

[Scrooge]

After reading October's thread on this. I looked first and was torn between 6.5 and 7.0, which it turns out is where Andy was. Now I know I follow the OGG a.k.a. the October Grading Guide

[divad]

After reading October's thread on this. I looked first and was torn between 6.5 and 7.0, which it turns out is where Andy was. Now I know I follow the OGG a.k.a. the October Grading Guide

 

That Guide's seriously out-of-date . . .