Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Daredevil 1 story complete Qualified.

22 posts in this topic

Since it's already missing pieces, would you mind cutting out the Spider-Man "stamp" on the front cover for me since he doesn't appear in the issue? No, oh okay.

 

Anyway, solid book but staining really hurts this one. VG.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Since it's already missing pieces, would you mind cutting out the Spider-Man "stamp" on the front cover for me since he doesn't appear in the issue? No, oh okay.

 

Anyway, solid book but staining really hurts this one. VG.

 

No problem, I'll use it for postage on your next package.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With the missing pin up and the water stain, I would say a 3.0...I can't see a VG book with a missing piece and a heavy water stain that goes through the entire top of the book.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With the missing pin up and the water stain, I would say a 3.0...I can't see a VG book with a missing piece and a heavy water stain that goes through the entire top of the book.

 

I think (Q) 4.0 gossip.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With the missing pin up and the water stain, I would say a 3.0...I can't see a VG book with a missing piece and a heavy water stain that goes through the entire top of the book.

 

I think (Q) 4.0 gossip.gif

 

I hate qualified grades and I never see CGC hand them out. If it has a huge water stain it's a 3.0 in my book. sumo.gif

 

I mean if you want to go the qualified route, every book can be a 10.0 (Q) if you list enough defects.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With the missing pin up and the water stain, I would say a 3.0...I can't see a VG book with a missing piece and a heavy water stain that goes through the entire top of the book.

 

I think (Q) 4.0 gossip.gif

 

I hate qualified grades and I never see CGC hand them out. If it has a huge water stain it's a 3.0 in my book. sumo.gif

 

I mean if you want to go the qualified route, every book can be a 10.0 (Q) if you list enough defects.

 

I was just stating that I think his grade was qualified, not a 4.0 with a missing non story page makepoint.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With the missing pin up and the water stain, I would say a 3.0...I can't see a VG book with a missing piece and a heavy water stain that goes through the entire top of the book.

 

I think (Q) 4.0 gossip.gif

 

I hate qualified grades and I never see CGC hand them out. If it has a huge water stain it's a 3.0 in my book. sumo.gif

 

I mean if you want to go the qualified route, every book can be a 10.0 (Q) if you list enough defects.

 

I was just stating that I think his grade was qualified, not a 4.0 with a missing non story page makepoint.gif

 

Oh, 27_laughing.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

With the missing pin up and the water stain, I would say a 3.0...I can't see a VG book with a missing piece and a heavy water stain that goes through the entire top of the book.

 

I think (Q) 4.0 gossip.gif

 

I hate qualified grades and I never see CGC hand them out. If it has a huge water stain it's a 3.0 in my book. sumo.gif

 

I mean if you want to go the qualified route, every book can be a 10.0 (Q) if you list enough defects.

 

I agree. I hate the "Q" thing also. But I think he was looking for a Q grade, so that's what I did. I mean...it would be obvious if we actually gave it the correct grade.

 

By the way my X-men #1, TOS #39 and JIM #83 ar all Qualified 10.0's. yay.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If the book is missing an entire page (i.e. the pinup) it is missing 2 full pages and is therefore incomplete. It does not qualify for a (Q) grade in the furthest reach of the imagination, particularly in such an apparent low grade. Furthermore, it would grade no higher than a 1.5 due to the missing pages. sumo.gif

 

sorry.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If the book is missing an entire page (i.e. the pinup) it is missing 2 full pages and is therefore incomplete. It does not qualify for a (Q) grade in the furthest reach of the imagination, particularly in such an apparent low grade. Furthermore, it would grade no higher than a 1.5 due to the missing pages. sumo.gif

 

sorry.gif

 

I consider the story complete, therefore I "qualify" the condition.

 

Call it a poor, call it a fair, call it a reader copy...it doesn't matter to me.....it's worth something to somebody, and likely will have to go the ebay route with all disclosures to get top dollar gossip.gif (which may not be that much) gossip.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites