PGM Creepy 28 This may be the one!

[CatskillMike]

c'mon baby! Nice corners on this one.

 

[KingOfRulers]

9.2; had it not been for the bend on the back cover I would have said 9.6.

[Pirate]

agree, that back cover hurts it.

[CatskillMike]

Yes, there's somrthing on the back cover. There is an ink smudge which I believe is from the printer and an ever so slight bend LLC. Is the ink smudge a factor if it is a printing defect?

[october]

It looks as nice, or nicer, than the slabbed magazine 9.4s I have owned or seen. So 9.4 at worst, but likely a 9.6.

 

If that's a 9.2 I will buy every magazine this forum can offer that looks like the one above. I wonder if you all grade your own books that harshly.....

[Pirate]

It looks as nice, or nicer, than the slabbed magazine 9.4s I have owned or seen. So 9.4 at worst, but likely a 9.6.

 

If that's a 9.2 I will buy every magazine this forum can offer that looks like the one above. I wonder if you all grade your own books that harshly.....

 

nope just ones with impact marks and to be honest i grade my own books harsher than any board as i would rather be off low than off high.

[october]

It looks as nice, or nicer, than the slabbed magazine 9.4s I have owned or seen. So 9.4 at worst, but likely a 9.6.

 

If that's a 9.2 I will buy every magazine this forum can offer that looks like the one above. I wonder if you all grade your own books that harshly.....

 

nope just ones with impact marks and to be honest i grade my own books harsher than any board as i would rather be off low than off high.

 

Do you have any 8.5-9.2s from the late silver or early bronze then? If you really grade them as tightly as the books on this forum I would be very interested....

[bounty_coder]

It looks as nice, or nicer, than the slabbed magazine 9.4s I have owned or seen. So 9.4 at worst, but likely a 9.6.

 

If that's a 9.2 I will buy every magazine this forum can offer that looks like the one above. I wonder if you all grade your own books that harshly.....

 

I would also say NM 9.4 on this one. The only thing I see wrong with this book is that slight crease to the back cover. Though It seems as if CGC handles creases in point deductions. And might grade this at a NM- 9.2.

 

I agree the spine is tight, corners are square and the bindery is nice, which is not too common.

 

Great book, probably a NM.

 

-bounty

[burntboy]

if the black smudge on the BC was discounted as a printing defect - 9.4, otherwise 9.2..................

[inconceivable]

NM 9.4 this is the best of the bunch Mike. So far...

 

Dan

[joeypost]

Reasonable shot at 9.4, but most likely a 9.2.