ASM # 3

[herald2galactus]

hey dudes, i have quite a little dilema..ive got this pretty little copy of asm# 3..its currently slabbed, but the slab is rickety.... while in slab it got a little chip on the top edge directly above the 2nd a in "amazing" now i kinda wanna resub it, but dont wanna get a much lower grade, so i need to know what u think? resub it and take a possible hit, or crack it and keep it raw?

bad scans i know, but its the best i can get

 

 

[herald2galactus]

that evil little chip.....

 

[Comicdey]

What's the grade now, the chip might not matter. Then again, if you're selling, that chip ruins the books as far as I'm concerned.

 

Why re-slab at this point?

 

It still looks great.

 

I'd either leave it as it or I'd just unslab it if that's the goal and save the label.

[herald2galactus]

What's the grade now, the chip might not matter. Then again, if you're selling, that chip ruins the books as far as I'm concerned.

 

Why re-slab at this point?

 

It still looks great.

 

I'd either leave it as it or I'd just unslab it if that's the goal and save the label.

its a 6.5 now, but the slab is really loose, and this is one of my display books, and i like the looks of the slab

but if its gonna get dropped significantly, its not worth the cash, and ill just keep it raw

[Dad&Son-migration]

I'd be leaving it but inform any potential buyers to take care when handling and let them decide. Otherwise I can't see it receiving the same grade. My dilemma in that advice is that I ask myself, and I think any potential buyer would ask, " Is it truly a 6.5 anymore?? "

[Aces]

I'd be leaving it but inform any potential buyers to take care when handling and let them decide. Otherwise I can't see it receiving the same grade. My dilemma in that advice is that I ask myself, and I think any potential buyer would ask, " Is it truly a 6.5 anymore?? "

 

You don't want to ship it like that!

 

Ask one of the green guys here if CGC will reholder it for free if something went wrong with the inner well.

[herald2galactus]

I'd be leaving it but inform any potential buyers to take care when handling and let them decide. Otherwise I can't see it receiving the same grade. My dilemma in that advice is that I ask myself, and I think any potential buyer would ask, " Is it truly a 6.5 anymore?? "

 

see im pretty sure a 6.5 is out of the question, and a 6.0 wouldnt bother me , but a 5.0 however,how bad do u guys think that chip would drop me

[Aces]

That's a small chip.

It might still get 6.5.

I've seen 8.5s with big marvel chips.

 

If it dropped more than .5 for that small chip you got screwed.

[Comicdey]

I'm not seeing a grade drop below 6.0

[herald2galactus]

thanks for the advice guys, im thinkin ill resub it, ill let u all know when it comes back

[Aces]

thanks for the advice guys, im thinkin ill resub it, ill let u all know when it comes back

 

PM Steve about this.

If it's a faulty inner well or some error on CGC's part they probably will reslab for free.

 

But I think you need to get the OK from him before you send it in.