GRADING CONTEST : Round 1

[Karma23]

with the majority nailing this one.

 

ditto

[FFB]

how does a corner crease get a 9.6

 

Ssssshhhhhh. No whining. Everyone else got it right, so it must be ok to have a 1/4 inch crease in a 9.6.

[MutantKeys]

how does a corner crease get a 9.6

 

Ssssshhhhhh. No whining. Everyone else got it right, so it must be ok to have a 1/4 inch crease in a 9.6.

Scott, I want to purchase you 11.0 ASM, PM me

[THE_BEYONDER]

I thought the LRC had a crease (looked that way in the scan) and was too lazy to ask the question.

 

To be honest with you, I saw that crease , flip floped..... and guessed wrong. I went with 9.4 thinking since it was a newer issue rather then older CGC gave it tough love.

 

Congrats to those who nailed it.

 

Ze-

 

Didn't even notice the crease. Took a quick glance at the corners & spine....graded it a NM+....then added .2 since it was recently graded.

 

On to the next round...

[divad]

how does a corner crease get a 9.6

 

Ssssshhhhhh. No whining. Everyone else got it right, so it must be ok to have a 1/4 inch crease in a 9.6.

 

Q: When is a corner crease not a corner crease?

 

A: When it doesn't exist except in your mind . . .

 

Actually, the soft ULFC had me leaning towards 9.4 . . .

[Sid]

I don't know what crease you guys are talking about but I went with a 9.4 due to the top spine :\

[FFB]

how does a corner crease get a 9.6

 

Ssssshhhhhh. No whining. Everyone else got it right, so it must be ok to have a 1/4 inch crease in a 9.6.

Scott, I want to purchase you 11.0 ASM, PM me

 

You can't afford it.

[DeeDee-migration]

I don't know what crease you guys are talking about but I went with a 9.4 due to the top spine :\

 

me too, ah well... on to the next one

 

[MutantKeys]

how does a corner crease get a 9.6

 

Ssssshhhhhh. No whining. Everyone else got it right, so it must be ok to have a 1/4 inch crease in a 9.6.

Scott, I want to purchase you 11.0 ASM, PM me

 

You can't afford it.

[Monstro]

[Sal]

yeah i changed my guess from a 9.6 to a 9.2 because of that corner crease.

[Monstro]

thats what i guessed

[divad]

 

Those are just "bruised" molecules . . .

[THE_BEYONDER]

To be completely honest.....I just couldn't see Nik submitting anything less than a 9.8 copy of that book. Hence my grade.

[MutantKeys]

[Silvers24]

I said 9.4, I should have just said 9.6

[toro]

Glad I didn't see it!

[s-man]

Glad I didn't see it!

 

Me 2!

[nik]

To be completely honest.....I just couldn't see Nik submitting anything less than a 9.8 copy of that book. Hence my grade.

 

Then you guys are in for a big surprise this time around

 

I figured most of you guys would think I would send in only books that would grade 9X

 

Not going to be that easy

[THE_BEYONDER]

Child's play...