KUDOS THREAD - positive feedback on buyers/sellers 0

[Rickdogg]

In that case...here is a list of positive transactions I have had with board members. Those highlighted in

blue are people that I would send books to on approval.

***The one highlighted in red is a negative!

 

Araich (private)

Bigman (In person and ebay)

Blazingbob (ebay & private)

Bluecollarjoe (ebay & private)

Bonds25 (ebay and private)

Bronty (private)

Bronzebruce13 (private)

Chromium (private)

Clobberintime (ebay)

Comgeek (ebay)

Comix4Fun (private)

dam60 (Private)

Darthdiesel (Ebay and private)

davidking623 (ebay and private)

Denofthieves (ebay and private)

Drdonaldblake (private)

Dungeon (private)

Greggy (ebay and private)

Griii (ebay and private)

Hitman (ebay)

HeritageJohn (ebay)

Ideal808 (ebay)

Jiveturkeymofo (private)

JLA_all_the_way (ebay and private)

Joecgcmaniac (ebay and private)

Jordanabigail (private)

Light_house (ebay and private)

Metropolisent (private)

MikeS (ebay & private)

Muaddib (Private)

Musicmeta (ebay & Private)

MW1 (Private)

Nochips (ebay & private)

Notch_Top (ebay)

Polyphemus (ebay)

Scottish (ebay)

Shieldagent (private)

Spidermanbeyond (Private)

Tegelaar (ebay)

Tkg2627 (ebay & private)

Vintagecomics (ebay; screwed me) ebay id's: gamecollector5, vintagecomics, vintagecomics2, videogameland

Wilquon (ebay and private)

Wolvergeek (private)

Yertle (private)

[ubiquiti]

People I have bought from or sold to:(all VERY positive)

Comicmankev

Darthdiesel

Dr.Banner

FlyingDonut

Greggy

Hogations

Lighthouse

Osborn-France

Polyphemus

Supapimp

[BronzeBruce13]

You may be on to something there Rick for those that want to get more technical with their feedback.

 

I'm glad you'd send me books on spec.

 

[davidking623]

David... so sorry. Your name seemed very familair but I was not sure.

I added you to the original post

 

 

BB13 <-----

 

Hi Bruce you cant remember every transaction. I am putting a list together and will have something to the nature of Speedjunkies it will be posted when I am sure I have everyones name although I am sure I will miss someone also.

 

Davidking623

[THE_BEYONDER]

Before I ever came to this forum, I bought a couple books from Banner. Aside from that, I've never had any transactions with forum members....

[greggy]

Before I ever came to this forum, I bought a couple books from Banner. Aside from that, I've never had any transactions with forum members....

[THE_BEYONDER]

Before I ever came to this forum, I bought a couple books from Banner. Aside from that, I've never had any transactions with forum members....

 

[greggy]

Before I ever came to this forum, I bought a couple books from Banner. Aside from that, I've never had any transactions with forum members....

 

Charity books don't count Chris?

[THE_BEYONDER]

Before I ever came to this forum, I bought a couple books from Banner. Aside from that, I've never had any transactions with forum members....

 

Charity books don't count Chris?

 

greggy.....

 

[greggy]

Before I ever came to this forum, I bought a couple books from Banner. Aside from that, I've never had any transactions with forum members....

 

Charity books don't count Chris?

 

greggy.....

[drbanner]

Succesful transactions with everyone below...judgement withheld on hammer's book pending consultation with my advisor!

 

all4comics

araich

awe4one

Blazing Bob

blowout

Bluecollarjoe

Bonds25

bronty

bronzebruce

bugaboo - I'm the only one??

cd4ever

chrisco37

chromium

clobberintime

comicdave

darthdiesel

delekkerste

fantasticfour

FlyingDonut

gman

greggy

hammer

Hogations

ideal808

JLA_all_the_way

Johnny Double

jordanabigail

Kevthemev

Lantern

lighthouse

loisandclark

majorkhaos

Mushroom

musicmeta

nochips

oldguy

povertyrow

realitytrip

RipVanSleep

Rob_react

speedjunkies

sullypython

the beyonder

tkg2627

ubiquiti

 

[greggy]

Why don't you out the ones who can't grade?

[musicmeta]

Hey, Thanks for making me blue.

[Rip]

Kudos to Banner. The ONLY forum member who's given me a raw book within 4 grades of what he said it was. He's a dead on grader. Thanks.

[greggy]

Kudos to Banner. The ONLY forum member who's given me a raw book within 4 grades of what he said it was. He's a dead on grader. Thanks.

[drbanner]

Kudos to Banner. The ONLY forum member who's given me a raw book within 4 grades of what he said it was. He's a dead on grader. Thanks.

 

You're welcome...I think?

[greggy]

Kudos to Banner. The ONLY forum member who's given me a raw book within 4 grades of what he said it was. He's a dead on grader. Thanks.

 

You're welcome...I think?

But....has anyone sold to banner a properly graded book?

[BronzeBruce13]

its a compliment... you're "dead on"... the others were NOT with in 4 grades in his opinion.

 

Your grading rep. is about the best out there Mike. I've never bought a "raw" book from you (and for the life of me I don't know why) but I know several that have and received very favorable results when your grading was tested at CGC. In fact, I heard of a key or 3 that came back .2/.4 higher because you graded down for production flaws.

 

You saw my CGC want list...if ever you have any "close" raw candidates.. PLEASE LMK.

 

 

 

 

 

[drbanner]

But....has anyone sold to banner a properly graded book?

 

Well...you, b/c you had me grade 'em!!

 

Hmmm...most of these are folks I sold books to, or bought graded books from. I do remember I bought some raw, accurately graded hi-grade Smurfs from Darth (find that treasury yet?), a nice mid-grade Timely from Donut, and some high-grade bronze Hulks from nochips. Too many to accurately remember...

[greggy]

But....has anyone sold to banner a properly graded book?

 

Well...you, b/c you had me grade 'em!!

 

Hmmm...most of these are folks I sold books to, or bought graded books from. I do remember I bought some raw, accurately graded hi-grade Smurfs from Darth (find that treasury yet?), a nice mid-grade Timely from Donut, and some high-grade bronze Hulks from nochips. Too many to accurately remember...

Welll...I kinda graded those Hot Wheels that will be sent. But...I have been coping out with the split grade junk! Never used to do it!