Superman #2

[Bonds25]

I'm at work and don't have an Overstreet. What does Superman #2 guide for in FN/VF? This price seems really fair, but maybe not?

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2190830135&category=35752

[aardvark88]

Looking at my 2 yr old Ostreet, fn = $3,060, nm = $12,750. Wow, Nic Cage had good taste under he married Lisa Marie.

[greggy]

3200 and 8000

[Bonds25]

I'm surprised the guide prices are that low. I guess the price he's asking isn't that great afterall.

 

P.S. Check your PM troll!

[greggy]

I'm surprised the guide prices are that low. I guess the price he's asking isn't that great afterall.

 

P.S. Check your PM troll!

Oh...you wanted me to respond to that PM? I deleted it hours ago!

[Bonds25]

Oh...you wanted me to respond to that PM? I deleted it hours ago!

 

[greggy]

Oh...you wanted me to respond to that PM? I deleted it hours ago!

 

Screw you and you stupid links to auctions!

[PovertyRow]

Latest OS for Superman 2:

 

G - 1067

VG - 2134

F - 3200

VF - 8000

VF/NM - 12,000

NM - 16,000

 

Not surprising. Number 2's are like driving a new car out of the lot. Instant depreciation!

[Bonds25]

Screw you and you stupid links to auctions!

 

Yea, I guess my posts should be more insightful like yours are. Is this good enough?

 

 

Or maybe this?

 

 

Or perhaps a simple

[greggy]

Screw you and you stupid links to auctions!

 

Yea, I guess my posts should be more insightful like yours are. Is this good enough?

 

 

Or maybe this?

 

 

Or perhaps a simple

[comicmankev]

Sold at Heritage for $5060 Lot: 5877, in July of this year. Can't thnk much would have changed in that amount of time. Apart from the divorse of course

[jkrk]

I agree that The Heritage auction basically prices the book. Maybe you could tack on a small premium for missing the auction. The question I have is:

 

Superman 1-3 sells somewhat above guide. Why doesn't overstreet more fully reflect the more accurate pricing of certain books that clearly sell above guide? I understand why they don't reduce prices and I understand if a movie is coming out that pushes the book up temporarily. It seems the early Supermen have been selling above guide for years.

[CosmicBob]

Sold at Heritage for $5060 Lot: 5877, in July of this year. Can't thnk much would have changed in that amount of time. Apart from the divorse of course

 

It failed to sell at last year's Heritage October Sale. Was that $5060 with the BP? If I had noticed it (which I should have, but somehow didn't) I would have paid $5060 for that one, easy. But I'm not paying $7000 or more for it.

 

It's a sweet book though.

[comicmankev]

Yes, the total price paid was $5060 including juices! I didnt think that was that bad looking back, but it's too late then!

[Thegoldenage]

I think that if the Superman 2 ended at 5060 with the juice, that is the current value of the book in the marketplace. Heritage is the auction house right now, and everyone who is someone watches their auctions. Of course, that doesn't mean that if you bid one more increment, you would have won it. The high bidder could have put in a secret maximum bid much higher.

[comicmankev]

Exactly what I said!

 

With anything rare that turns up for sale, if it is truly rare, the value of that item is what it last sold for!

[harveyfan323]

It's amazing that X-Men 94 CGC 9.6 sold for about $6000 a couple of weeks ago on ebay, yet this book is priced about the same and has to be much more rare.