JD717

Update, CGC said it will be up to Todd to decide. If he does not sign it, I won’t be charged. 

On 9/8/2022 at 8:39 AM, lostboys said:

He wont sign this? How come?

 

I’m not sure why. Wish I could be more helpful. This book was on his will not sign list on CGC’s site from 2019.

On 9/7/2022 at 6:00 PM, Ed Hanes said:

I sent in the homage issue 306 ..some consider it a parody..but he has signed this particular issue before. But I think what he means by parody are artists who parody his ASM 300 image 

Gotcha! I feel confident he would sign it, but I’d rather get confirmation than solely rely on my gut. 

Hi everyone,

I have a few comics I’d like to get signed by TM. One that I have is a variant cover of TM Spider-Man #1 Torment Part 1. This was done by Matt Dimasi a few years ago.  
 

Is this something that TM would sign? I emailed Customer Service, but curious if a mod or someone might have any input. 
 

Attached is a copy of what I’m talking about. 
 

Thanks!

On 9/7/2022 at 5:36 PM, Ed Hanes said:

Todd McFarlane will NOT sign any of these books during the CGC In-House Private Signing:Venom #1 Color Variant Cover, Venomverse #1 B&W Variant, Venomverse #1 Color, Venom #6 Color Variant Edition, Spawn Retailer Thank You Variant. TODD WILL NOT SIGN ANY PARODY COVERS. He will only sign books and characters he has worked on.

Thanks! I saw that and some of the examples, but I wonder if the above still applies? I sent an email to customer service, so hopefully I get some good news. If it’s eligible great. If not, no worries and I get to save some money!

On 9/7/2022 at 2:58 PM, 'Lorider said:

It took about 30 seconds to find this on Ebay:

Thanks! Couldn’t find any signed by TM. Sent an email to customer service for confirmation so hopefully get some good news. 

On 9/7/2022 at 2:53 PM, 'Lorider said:

No, not really. CGC goes by the indicia for the title, which is the small print company info.  The other problem with this variant is that I don't think it's officially published by Marvel? It's like an aftermarket/personal art kind of thing, I'm not sure. The other thing to do is check sites like Ebay, MCS, HA, etc for the same book and see how the title is listed on the slab.

I don't know how you would search by cover but CGC is correct to use the indicia and keep everything standard. It's not CGC 's job to hold people by the hands when they can easily find it themselves.

For a newbie, it’s not very intuitive. At the very least, include what you mentioned somewhere on the page.

On 9/7/2022 at 2:52 PM, revat said:

You can consider contacting Cgc directly about whatever list of exclusions exist, get an official answer.

Then at minimum you have some recourse if you get ultimately rejected.

I personally would send an email to customers service  for a document trail.

Already sent an email yesterday. Figured I’d ask here, too. Hopefully I get some good news!

Not me but close! Thanks for the feedback. I’ll need to figure out how to post in the other section. Don’t want to risk sending this out and getting charged for nothing. 
 

Also, the submission form for entering my comic title is poorly designed. Took me several tries of typing different phrases to find my comics. CGC should implement a search by cover or artist feature for what they charge. 

Will Todd sign the Dimasi shattered comicbook?