Comics4Stone

On 12/17/2022 at 5:10 PM, BlowUpTheMoon said:

Hi love the comic.    I was wondering just curious.  If one of as able to put chase or come into possession of a cover front ant back page (the covers only) of this comic.   Would it be beneficial to add it to the interior pages here and submit it for grading to cgc as a detached cover but a complete comic? Get a higher grade?   What you think? For this one.    

On 12/17/2022 at 5:10 PM, BlowUpTheMoon said:

Hello everyone Im just a young man that loves to collect comics ever since my father left me his collection from 60's and 70's 80's.  I came across last week a comic Journey into mystery #83 that only had the the inside complete story all pages  the 1st  and 2nd page are detached from the rest of the pages which are still on the staples but its all their.  but is flat really flat and in good shape for its age... so its missing the cover front and back...    Now it just so happens my dad had also in the collection in another box he has a cover of the same comic journey into mystery #83 front & back.   now I'm not a grader or professional. but it seems not to be to the same comic   or it is I'm not sure..  now after seeing what their going for I said I have to submit and grade this...        I'm talking a lot...  QUESTION IS   should I / can I submit this and put the inside complete story all pages inside the original cover my dad had and just submit it as one comic and not be a considered a reconstruction would leave like the two pages  just add the cover detached and old ??  how would this look to CGC for grading?     or should I just send them separately to be graded?    be nice to have it all together   I'm going for a 2.0. low expectations.    What do you think it would grade at in this condition with complete story and pages all the insides only?

be nice to hear also from CGC grading directly on this question and hear their suggestions

thank you for your time and looking forward to your responses.   

so the quest

thank you... i got all excited this is what collecting comics is all about finding a little treasure.... loved my dad also for passing his collection and hopbby to me.  great memories

On 12/12/2022 at 7:32 PM, flashlites said:

There is a thread for just this kind of question!

https://boards.cgccomics.com/forum/42-hey-buddy-can-you-spare-a-grade/

thanks for the link .... ill post my question their

Hello everyone Im just a young man that loves to collect comics ever since my father left me his collection from 60's and 70's 80's.  I came across last week a comic Journey into mystery #83 that only had the the inside complete story all pages  the 1st  and 2nd page are detached from the rest of the pages which are still on the staples but its all their.  but is flat really flat and in good shape for its age... so its missing the cover front and back...    Now it just so happens my dad had also in the collection in another box he has a cover of the same comic journey into mystery #83 front & back.   now I'm not a grader or professional. but it seems not to be to the same comic   or it is I'm not sure..  now after seeing what their going for I said I have to submit and grade this...        I'm talking a lot...  QUESTION IS   should I / can I submit this and put the inside complete story all pages inside the original cover my dad had and just submit it as one comic and not be a considered a reconstruction would leave like the two pages  just add the cover detached and old ??  how would this look to CGC for grading?     or should I just send them separately to be graded?    be nice to have it all together   I'm going for a 2.0. low expectations. 

be nice to hear also from CGC grading directly on this question and hear their suggestions

thank you for your time and looking forward to your responses.   

so the quest