• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

tpetty

Member
  • Posts

    132
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by tpetty

  1. If CC/CL and Heritage both have the same book, with the exact same CGC grade, then I will bid less on the book on Heritage because of the extra buyer's fee, which most people take into account - so that my FINAL, REAL purchase price is the roughly the same on either site after taking into account the Heritage vig.  While it's possible that if someone bids similarly on both sites (without factoring in the buyer's premium) because they don't understand the process, and that drives the total purchase price a little higher, it is the auction house - not the seller - that is making more.

  2. I didn't mean to start a new topic on this.  I had searched for the connect thread, and didn't get any recent results - didn't realize I had to look almost a month back!

    I don't like the BP idea at all.  I tolerate it at Heritage, because I figure it pays for the nice catlaogs, GPA links, the GREAT website with easy past auction searches as a price reference, etc - but not enthused about it at CC for what seems to be a vastly inferior web site, search, organization, etc.

    Seems a very poor idea - and I agree that they should have just made a deal with the seller for a reduced commission behind the scenes.

  3. I was just bidding on some books in the current Comic Connect auction, and see that many of them now also include a 15% Buyer's premium in addition to the bid.  I've been used to factoring that in with Heritage in the past, but don't recall it with CC.  Is this something new?  It's possible I just haven't been paying attention...

  4. I'm still annoyed by how inaccurate golden age prices are.  I hear the arguments - price guides are out of date as soon as printed, it's a "guide" only - so doesn't have to be accurate, he doesn't like changing prices too "quickly."  It's all ridiculous.  I buy mostly good girl art type covers, and have for years.  For many years, you can not get a nice Rangers, Fight Comics, Junior Comics, Schomburg covers, etc etc etc without paying multiple times guide. 

    Multiple times.  For years.  and years.

    I see no GOOD reason why the guide doesn't more accurately reflect prices.  And I'm not a high roller - i am usually buying books under 1K, so it's not as if sales are rare. Many, many books have been out of whack for a long time.

  5. Yep. 

    With that in mind (even though I hope to not die for another 30-40 years) I have started to sell the 80s-90s comics I accumulated as a kid.  Most of this era of comics are not worth much, but I have sold a couple long boxes worth on ebay, and have many boxes still to go.  Some go decent (Infinity Gauntlet, McFarlane Spiderman, Miller Daredevil, etc.)  If I can't get about 20% guide I put them in a donate box for a tax write off. 

    Yes - 20% guide - and many aren't selling at that price.  (Not touching my slabbed golden age comics, but those will be relatively easy to sell.  It's the low value common copper/modern age ones - not unlike the funny animal books in this thread - that take work.)

  6. I bought a 6.0 universal slabbed Mystery men Comics from Heritage 6 years ago.  I just got an offer of $1300 for it, so after Heritage's 10% cut comes out to $1170 for me.  (For those that have never gone through Heritage's anonymous offer format, I am responsible for shipping/insurance to Dallas)

    I don't have GPA, so don't know if that is a good offer.   It's more than Overstreet, but I think Mystery Men often goes for well over Overstreet.  Via searching completed auctions, I see a 6.5 sold several years ago via Heritage for over $3k - but I don't know if that was an aberration.

    Can anyone help with a realistic current day "value?"  Thanks.