askyla

Wow, I didn't realize it'd lower the grade that much. This is my first time having any kind of problem from their site - usually they're great. I guess it's not worth returning it, but it is really annoying. I hope it'd at least pass for a 9.2, then.

Hey everyone! I just received this J Scott Campbell variant for Astonishing X-Men #1 (Cover B), and I noticed there was some cover flaking in the top left corner. I just wanted to know if you could lend me some of your expertise - is this a big deal? Is it worth returning it over this? Would J Scott Campbell's store even consider this a "defect"? I wasn't planning on getting it graded, but I'd like the peace of mind to know it's at least a 9.6. The rest of the book is flawless. Thank you so much!

Thank you very much!

Bump? Does anyone know how much a defect like this usually affects the grading of a book? Thanks again, I appreciate your time

Hey everyone, I recently purchased the J Scott Campbell ASM #700 variant set with the accompanying Superior Spider-Man #1. However, I noticed that the bottom left corner of ASM #700 seems to have some damage (most likely due to Midtown comics' poor shipping, as I've had similar problems in the past.) I am not as in-depth a collector as some here - I love variants, but I don't usually get anything CGC'd. I'd like to believe most of my comics are in great condition, so this little flaw is bothering me. I know the pictures aren't the greatest quality, as all I really wanted to learn about was this specific corner, but could you please help me out? I was hoping for at least a 7 or 7.5. The rest of the book looks fantastic. Thanks again, I really appreciate it!