poppy73

Right now I think the best looking covers are the Star Wars Action Figure Variants. 

8.5 IMHO

I'm going with a 6.5..

8.0 As it stands. Maybe 9.0 with a press. Nice book!

Wow that's faded.. 3.5 to 4.0..

3.0 to 3.5 here too..

I wouldn't send it in personally. Keep it as a raw readers copy and keep searching for the elusive 9.8..

16 hours ago, Johnny545 said:

Find another 9.4

Bump...

I'm also at 9.6 to 9.8. But leaning toward 9.8. I've sent in books that I thought were absolutely flawless but received a 9.6. The devils in the details but I'd roll the dice and submit it.

3.5 to 4.0. due to the staining on the book and the rough corners and edges. Nice book though!

7.0. Nice looking book with some minor issues. 

I'm a bit more optimistic. I give it a 7.5. Nice copy. 

Copy A 6.0 due to spine issues

Copy B 7.0 due to minor spine issues and dirt on the back cover

Still nice books!

Amazing book. I'd grade it at a 6.5. 

Great book. One of my favorites. I'd speculate a 6.5. 

Place a colored piece of paper under your scans so the edges and corners are more visible. It makes it much easier to speculate as to what the potential grade may be. Nice book! I have one as well but it's a 9.0. I believe it was the first book I ever had graded. Good luck!

On 9/26/2017 at 8:12 AM, Kevin76 said:

Been pressing my own books for a while now, here are a few before and afters I just did.  

 

Very impressive work! I'm always amazed at how pressing when done correctly can make a book like new.. Great job!

I'd give it a 5.0. Great book! I'm jealous:)

Nice book! I'd give it a 7.0 due to spine tics, minor corner blunting and dirt or discoloring on the backside of the book.

9.0 all day long..

I love this book. I'd grade it at 8.0..

I concur. 5.0. 

5.5 with a press. As another member stated, CGC tends to grade higher when you have them press and clean the book.

I have the same issue with my copy of the same book and what appears to be staining by the top staple on the back side. Otherwise my copy like yours is beautiful. I'd give yours a 9.8. Mine has a bit of spine roll which would probably take it down to a 9.6 but the book doesn't warrant spending the money on pressing. I'm not sure if I'm going to send mine in to be graded yet.

Based on the scans I'd say 7.5. If the dirt is truly an artifact from scanning the I'd bump the grade to an 8.5. Either way it's a nice book!