Jibber82

On 3/6/2024 at 10:23 PM, Lightning55 said:

If they feel it's a production flaw common to a specific issue, they will ignore it.

Shortly after they came out, I bought 100 each of Thor 337,338, and 339 for $300 total. A couple of years ago I had about 80 of each graded. A lot of the 337's and 338's had chips out of the corners, and still graded well. But out of all those 337's, I only got three 9.8's, none that were chipped.

Like they say, buy the book, not the label. I wouldn't want a chipped 9.8. A better one will come along.

Thank you! Very helpful reply. I decided not to purchase it. Bummer because I was excited to get this book in the PC.

Why would this book get a 9.8? Does CGC not take chips into account when grading?

Gabriele Dell'Otto

Clayton Crain (another one)

Skan

Joe Jusko

I'm guessing this was a mistake by CGC and not evidence of a new policy.

No it's a 9.8

I sent a Gamora #1 signed by J. Scott Campbell to CGC to get graded. The signature wasn't witnessed so I expected a green label. I got the graded book back yesterday and it has a blue label. The signature is very noticeable in pink marker. I'm not really upset by this I just found it interesting and thought I would share. Has this ever happened to anyone else?

How does this work? Will CGC already be at the artists booth or do I need to find a CGC representative and bring them with me to the artist booth?