Mrluvaluva

8.5/9.0 majority of problems on back cover are pretty minor. Nice book

3.5/4 I think closer to 3.5 with the soiling but just my opinion

I think the board in general grades conservatively

I have a feeling it is nicer in hand

4.5/5 for me 

24 minutes ago, kav said:

I think it's the extent to which they've done it.  After the junkie issue of GL they didn't make junkies in every single DC title for the next 5 years.  People get sick of being preached to.  WE GOT IT-DRUGS ARE BAD.

Exactly

I blame Disney for ESPN and Marvel. It is obvious to me and anyone else that has their eyes open. What I want to know is why does Disney want to bring politics and social pc into sports and comics. Are we ignorant heathen that needed more exposure to that ? Sports and comics are an escape from that very world. I don't want them mixed and I suspect I'm not alone judging from ESPN and Marvel losing money so fast

7/7.5 for me. Very nice copy

I'm at 9.2

18 hours ago, Glassman10 said:

Hard grading. I see some corner rounding. I see some slight yellowing on the upper rear spine but nothing that drags it down. I see an 8.5.  I'm trying to understand how an objective grading system would differentiate between a silver age and a bronze age book. Isn't grading supposed to be objective, not ageist?

 

I feel like cgc is softer on silver. Just my opinion. Also if this book is indeed normally sharp I'd say 9 is definitely out. I'm guessing said foxing is near mini iron man icon on cover. I missed that. If that's a stain even I'd say 8.0 at best. Still a super nice book imo

I'll chime in at 8.0-8.5 looks a little dirty otherwise I'd be solid 8.5 with possible 9.0 not sure how sharp this book gets so I could be a little lenient as I'm treating more like a silver book

I'll go 9.0-9.2 I haven't sent any books into cgc for a while though. The front looks good. Not sure if thats a scuff or scratch on botton of back cover but assumed it was.