Apg9176

Yeah they gave me 9's for all 3. I can see 252 being around 9.0 9.2. I've seen worse 9.0's

Well I sold the copy, but here's the 238 cracked. Still think cgc screwed me on it. No way this is 9.0 maybe 9.4 9.6. White pages throughout. The picture makes it look worse than actually looks on the back top left corner.

I just sent this in right after 238.. it had 1 dent nonbreaking on the back slight tick on the front that is hard to see. Everything was pressed out. Waiting for this come back 8.5 lol.. I don't think I'd be surprised if came back 9.4 or less 

More side pics

I think I got hosed on the 238

Here you guys go All 9.0 grades. You can say they were real consistent with this batch I received back. To answer the question. NO absolutely no grader notes. Here's your 9's thanks for your money. I'm sorry I can agree with 252 being even 9.2 but the 238 abd 361 shouldn't been lower than 9.4 

It's just the case

wait till show you other 2 tomorrow. But all the guess have been pretty good so far

Okay so I'm gonna show you 361 grading. Here was the finale grade for 361 I just received last week. I have side by side photo of another 361 i got back thats 9.8 from couple years ago. In my opinion think they were real quick to grade. Again Subjective but i find hard to believe when comparing the 2. You guys be the judge

Just so you guys know all the books were pressed before being sent in

You guys are pretty good. I'll hand it to you. Thought miswrap wouldnt count aginist grading though? Not 9.9 or 10 if perfect otherwise right?

You guys are pretty good. I'll hand it to you. Thought miswrap wouldnt count aginist grading though? Not 9.9 or 10 if perfect otherwise right?

So what do think finale assessment of the 238?

Point five maybe you can help me see the scuffs on the back? Other than the miswrap on the 238.. 361 doesn't seem like it's been touched? 252 I can see what you mean. I have another 361 that I can compare this grade 2 on Friday. I'll even take them side by side and you can guess which one is what

On 1/26/2022 at 11:20 PM, Point Five said:

All three look great at a glance, but appear to have slight scuffs and dents (particularly on the backs) that will take down the technical grades. Hard to see these really well, but my guesses:

ASM 238 - 7.5

ASM 361 - 8.0

ASM 252 - 7.5

 

I tried to brighten the images on the front and back for you everyone. Hopefully this helps.. in order back to front 238,252,361. 

I wish all of you were grading my books lmao...  by chance is there a professional grader in the house that might wanna take stab? Someone that really has an eye for a grade? You guys are doing great... think you'll all be surprised on Friday 

Thanks for the guessing everyone. Keep it going Friday I'll post the grades. 

Anyone else wanna take a stab?

Interesting! Okay let's keep it rolling... I'm going show the grades on Friday. 

Hello everyone I recently received my order back from cgc and curious think what everyone thinks these grades are? In order ASM 238 (Hobgoblin) ASM 252 (Black Suit) and ASM 361 (Carnage).. Want others opinions...grading is of course subjective and I understand that. I'll reveal the grades later this week. If you need more pictures or zoomed in or any questions about a mark on any books I'll gladly answer.  Thanks for the time

So I got the comics back 361.362.363. All off eBay for 100 bucks . Graded at 9.8 all 3!!!!

On 9/7/2018 at 2:09 AM, joeypost said:

What is the red lump in the right corner background?

It's a rock salt lamp

5 hours ago, Bomber-Bob said:

Why does it stink ? Let me ask you a question, if you bought a 9.8 and upon receiving it the book had a noticable color breaking spine tick, would you be happy ? People expect a 9.8 to look perfect. It may not be perfect but the flaws should not be as obvious as a color breaking spine tick. IMO, a 9.8 should have a perfect spine. I'm sorry but your book is no better than 9.6, no matter how much you keep asking. BTW, I'm sure if you keep asking someone will come on here and say you can get a 9.8. 

Oh. I didn't mean it stinks as in a bad thing. Just sucks because the book is in great shape. Wouldn't be upset with 9.6.. New this just trying to get an idea. Sounds like 20% chance it's gonna be 9.8.. Again thanks for the responses 

1 hour ago, The Lions Den said:

Believe it or not, that particular flaw has always been strictly enforced in a 9.8 or higher, at least in my experience.  

Intresting. So you're saying there's a chance?

6 minutes ago, Not A Clone said:

Yeah they are pretty strict right now. 1 color break seems to be an automatic 9.6 even if it's tiny. 

damn. that stinks. i know its not even a bad tick neither. oh well thanks for the advice