TOS 51....another one going to CGC just to test the waters

[Comicdey]

I will be getting three of those member only passes for grading...

 

What high $$ books to send with those puppies....? A few of these were de-slabbed, so no real hurry for those.

 

TOS 39

B&B34

ACTION 30

Planet 1

Zoot 14

Zoot 10

All Star 9

All American 17

All American 21

All American 23

TEC 30

AF 15

ASM 1

FF 1

 

 

[piper]

I will be getting three of those member only passes for grading...

 

What high $$ books to send with those puppies....? A few of these were de-slabbed, so no real hurry for those.

 

TOS 39

B&B34

ACTION 30

Planet 1

Zoot 14

Zoot 10

All Star 9

All American 17

All American 21

All American 23

TEC 30

AF 15

ASM 1

FF 1

 

 

My answer would depend on the following:

 

Do you plan on selling any of the above?

Are any restored?

Are any high grade?

 

If my memory serves me, I believe the AA's and Tec are restored, the AF15 is low grade and the TOS 39 is VF+. Based on that, I would get the TOS 39, Planet 1 and FF1 graded. (subject to answers to above questions)

 

Great books!

 

John

 

[Comicdey]

no plans on selling any of them.

 

The TEC was a restored 9.0

 

The TOS is a VF+ IMO unrestored

 

The AA's are not restored, the 17 was a 4.5, the 21 was sold to me in the VF- range if I recall correctly and from the INT. collection. The 23 I purchased raw and it's somewhere in the 5.0 range...can't recall what it was sold as right now.

 

The B&B 34 and Showcase 30 are VF+ unrestored or so

 

Action 30 is a VF/NM or VF+ unrestored

 

Planet #1 is F/VF or so restored (not sure how much or A/P...likely considered P)

 

All Star 9 is a FN+ IMO unrestored

 

Zoot 10 and 14 are VF or better unrestored

 

AF 15 FA/GD or G- (unrestored I believe, but tape inside)

FF 1 G/VG or so (has a slight A tear seal with glue on the edge)

ASM 1 VG- or so unrestored IMO.

 

Realistically, I guess I should have the highest dollar books graded with the freebies. ??

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Comicdey]

Officially mailed to CGC

[Comicdey]

Wow...

 

6.5 to 9.2.....

 

Who's got the beer goggles on?

[divad]

Wow...

 

6.5 to 9.2.....

 

Who's got the beer goggles on?

 

Without a doubt the 9.2 . . . .

 

Uh, good luck

 

[Comicdey]

...I agree 9.2 would be pie in the sky...but I've held the book in hand....I'm still betting 8.0. We'll see.

[trmoore54]

I voted 8.0...good luck!

[CAP Freak]

8.5 my vote

 

[gernblanston]

My vote is a firm 8.5 on this one. Good luck.

[Comicdey]

Ok guys...the verdict is in

 

CGC 8.5 OW/W

[divad]

[supapimp]

WOW! congrats, looks like there are a lot of tough graders here, i voted 7.5.

[Comicdey]

That was my original grade from eons ago on the mylar. (7.5) but I'm not surprised it made a CGC 8.0 and higher at 8.5.

[Comicdey]

You were only 1/2 grade off with 7.5 vs 8.5....remember old school...............

 

F/VF 7.0

VF- 7.5 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

VF 8.0

VF+ 8.5 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

VF/NM 9.0

NM- 9.2

NM 9.4

 

Now if you were a full Ebay 1 or 2 grades off, we'd have to have a talk.

[Aces]

 

It's always nice to do a little better than expected.

[trmoore54]

You've got some nice TOS's Collin...glad I could help add a couple to your heap!