PGM FF 12 - 1st SA Marvel cross-over - POLL

[rjpb]

I'm the party pooper who went 3.5 - the light grey cover hides the chipping to some degree - but if the cover were darker it would be quite noticable. I admit to not caring for chipping when it's in a few different places - it indicates brittleness at the edges of the cover. CGC would likely go higher as they are way too lenient with Marvel chipping from what I've seen. Without it I could see 5.5/6.0 - and it's a clean looking copy - even with the chippping the eye appeal is nice - though largely due to the fact that it blends in.

 

[joeypost]

4.5

[Old Fashion PB and J]

I went with 4.0 but admit to not being the best at lower grades. 4.5 would be my highest. The book is really nice, but the chipping bothers me. I guess preference comes heavy into play. If you dont mind it, then easy 5.0

[Dollarbill]

5.0

I love that cover-one of my favorites

[trmoore54]

I voted 5.0 (it's certainly 4.5 minimum)...Marvel chipping doesn't bother me much, especially when the rest of the book is in nice shape...I've got a TOS #8 that is freaking 9.0+ with fairly serious right edge chipping that, to me, is like a date stamp...just part of the book and it's production era/history...