Grading contest--Make your guesses now

[143ksk]

Big congrats to djpinkpanther

 

PM me to set up your prize

[John R]

Thanks again for this fun contest 143ksk and congrats to djpinkpanther!

[zzutak]

A great contest, to be sure. A neat selection of seldom seen 10-cent era books and a suspenseful reveal. Many thanks! (thumbs u (thumbs u Steve, which book/grade surprised you the most? For me, it was Book 8 (Tip Top #186, CGC 7.5 versus my 6.0). Whiff-ola!

[Cimm]

Apparently, I can't grade a scan for spit...

[143ksk]

A great contest, to be sure. A neat selection of seldom seen 10-cent era books and a suspenseful reveal. Many thanks! (thumbs u (thumbs u Steve, which book/grade surprised you the most? For me, it was Book 8 (Tip Top #186, CGC 7.5 versus my 6.0). Whiff-ola!

 

I was very pleasantly surprised by the Tip Top as well (actually by both of them--I had them both at 5.0 if that makes you feel any better )

 

Most of the other surprises were in the other 20 books in the submission. Maybe I should do another contest

[zzutak]

Actually, it does. I also had the Tip Top #187 (Book 9, CGC 6.0) pegged as a 5.0. Apparently, the boys in Sarasota are quite enamored with the Peanuts gang.

[bryan91]

Thanks for the fun contest.

 

I think you should do another one so I can try and redeem myself.

[topofthetotem]

I enjoyed this contest very much,thanks Steve!

 

Congrats to Thomas for pulling off the win.

[AJD]

That was fun, and it was a great selection of books.