The 2010 Nik Memorial Grading Contest *Round 15*

[joeypost]

There's an impact crease there (thumbs u

 

No impact crease on bottom left corner FC

Top right corner FC is production related. It is a wrinkle in the paper that has ink over it.

Top left corner FC is also production related but it does have a little additional wear.

Spine has 2 minor breaking creases.

 

Looking at this book in-hand I would say it is a 9.4.

[TheWatcher]

Well it sure as hell looks like an impact crease. Btw, why wasn't this info shared with the rest of the room when the scans went up

[DrWatson]

Next round won't even have scans.

[TheWatcher]

Sweet!

[worldsbestcomics]

Next round won't even have scans.

 

Nik could nail the grade just by me telling him the defects over the phone. The force was strong with him.

[DrWatson]

We'll be sending the next one out telepathically.

[etanick]

Well it sure as hell looks like an impact crease. Btw, why wasn't this info shared with the rest of the room when the scans went up

+1

 

that is the reason I thought the book was at best a 9.2 and I talked myself into a 9.0

 

and I went out and got new glasses last week....I guess there isn't a prescription to prevent hallunication