Hmm? 9.8 Bronze Captain America? 9.6? 2.0? Tell me what you think!

[divad]

Here's one from the boxes . . .

 

 

 

cheers,

[deathlok]

now that's a good looking book! couple of spine stresses which would make it probably a 9.4, although a good candidate for 9.6.

[supapimp]

9.2 maybe a 9.4 if the graders hit the pipe, but too many colour breaking spine stress.

[Fan4Fan]

What kind of boxes? Surely not quarter bins?

 

Anyhow, 9.4 verging on 9.6.

 

Thanks,

Fan4Fan

[divad]

And then, there is this one too:

 

 

 

[supapimp]

this one is a 9.2 for sure, LRC blunt knocks it out of solid 9.4.

[divad]

What kind of boxes? Surely not quarter bins?

 

Anyhow, 9.4 verging on 9.6.

 

Thanks,

Fan4Fan

 

Yeah . . . right - my tomato boxes, of course. In fact I pulled the whole 4-issue X-Men crossover run:

 

 

 

they just keep comin' . . .

[deathlok]

this not so good. 9.0-9.2 corners too rounded and more spine breaks

 

 

*edit*

ummm... I didn't notice that area above NF's head on the right side. I would have to lower my grade to 7.5.

[supapimp]

the #173 is a 7.0-7.5, nice books that you got to cherry pick from the drug store though. what else you got?

[nik]

I can see the Cap #174 coming back with a CGC grade of 9.4, 9.6 might be stretching a litle, but I have been wrong before.

But Cap #175, IMO is not as sharp, (cover wise) and it looks to be in the

9.0/9.2 range.

 

 

Nik

[divad]

this one is a 9.2 for sure, LRC blunt knocks it out of solid 9.4.

 

Supa,

 

Well, of course I was going to lead with my best,

 

The first and final book of the run:

 

 

 

Should I offer them individually? Or as a group?

[supapimp]

love the old skool banshee cover 6.5, as for selling them....dunno, start a poll maybe.

[deathlok]

172: URC ugh. The back cover center has the rip in it. spine breaks.

 

I say 6.5-7.0

[divad]

love the old skool banshee cover 6.5, as for selling them....dunno, start a poll maybe.

 

Geez,

 

I've had these books for 30 years and you guys can grade them in 30 seconds - wiithout even holding them no less!

[FFB]

9.2 maybe a 9.4 if the graders hit the pipe, but too many colour breaking spine stress.

 

Ditto, although I think 9.4 is within the realm of possibility from what I can see. I'm pretty comfortable that it's not a 9.6 though.

[FFB]

this one is a 9.2 for sure, LRC blunt knocks it out of solid 9.4.

 

I agree, though I think a 9.0 is also possible. There's some long spine stresses that put it on the cusp of those two grades, plus the corners are blunted/rounded.

[FFB]

love the old skool banshee cover 6.5, as for selling them....dunno, start a poll maybe.

 

I think 6.5 is too harsh on #172. I'd say maybe 7.5 or so.

[Aces]

172 6.5/7.0

 

173 VF 8.0

 

174 NM 9.4 Get it slabbed!

 

175 VF+/VF-NM 8.5/9.0

[divad]

172 6.5/7.0

 

173 VF 8.0

 

174 NM 9.4 Get it slabbed!

 

175 VF+/VF-NM 8.5/9.0

 

Aces,

 

Thanks, but why bother? I doubt I''d get more than $50 for it slabbed, if that. Why give CGC 70% of my gross (and probably 80% of my net) on this book? On just the chance it may hit a 9.6?

 

Been there, done that - I'd rather sell it raw.

 

[uclapeterg]

175: 9.2

 

174: 9.0

 

173: 7.5

 

172: 8.0