CGC Graded Kull the Conqueror #5 - what do you think?

[oakman29]

9.0 (thumbs u

[telerites]

9.0 (thumbs u

 

Yep that's the grade - a few of you hit it. I really thought it was a 9.4. My grading skills suffer woefully.

 

I knew the pages were crisp and white and in hand it sure looks nice but I need to shave off more for those corners.

 

Not much reason to have subbed it even as a 9.4 but I needed one last book for my 15 book value tier submission and this one was handy.

 

Thanks for sharing your thoughts, folks.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[ImperiusRex]

Interesting, I was expecting it to be higher. Have you thought about contacting JoeyPost and having the corners pressed? Couldn't hurt, and if you resub maybe go to a 9.2 or 9.4. Not sure what held the book down...

[Wilson3d]

I would of lost the farm on that bet. I looked at a lot of CGC scans of 9.4s before answering and really felt like I nailed it. Thanks a lot for posting it. I would like to do more of that on here! Lots of fun.

 

 

 

***Edit***Is that just for the corners or if the cover was black would we see alot of color breaking creases? I just don't see many 9.0s with only corner issues and the one small dent in the bottom right area.

[telerites]

I would of lost the farm on that bet. I looked at a lot of CGC scans of 9.4s before answering and really felt like I nailed it. Thanks a lot for posting it. I would like to do more of that on here! Lots of fun.

 

 

 

***Edit***Is that just for the corners or if the cover was black would we see alot of color breaking creases? I just don't see many 9.0s with only corner issues and the one small dent in the bottom right area.

 

None that I see in hand.