The Daily Grade: The Holy Grail - AF #15

[stynxno]

1.5

[davidking623]

1.0Davidking623

DK,With all due respect, I believe it qualifies on every point for a GD 2.0. The only borderline detail is the right edge, and how you read the OS guide. Certainly no lower than a 1.8 cheers,divad

Click to view supersized image

Click to view supersized image

 

 

Reliable image hosting provided by Vendio. Unlimited images for $12.95.

With the most respect of a gentleman and not hating your book but completely appreciating it fully Divad I must say maybe I jumped the gun but feel after a more further review!1.5Davidking623

[davidking623]

1.0Davidking623

DK,With all due respect, I believe it qualifies on every point for a GD 2.0. The only borderline detail is the right edge, and how you read the OS guide. Certainly no lower than a 1.8 cheers,divad

Agreed. That book is way better than 1.0. 1.0 is bordering on uncollectible. A total P.O.S. in every way, with large chunks of the cover missing (the entire back cover can be GONE in this grade, or up to 1/4 of the front cover missing). This book is probably a 2.0, maybe a 1.8 on a bad day.

Click to view supersized image

 

 

Reliable image hosting provided by Vendio. Unlimited images for $12.95.

After further review! 1.5Davidking623

[divad]

Now, THAT'S service! Thank you, kind sir!

[divad]

1.0

 

Davidking623

 

DK,

With all due respect, I believe it qualifies on every point for a GD 2.0. The only borderline detail is the right edge, and how you read the OS guide. Certainly no lower than a 1.8

cheers,

divad

 

Agreed. That book is way better than 1.0. 1.0 is bordering on uncollectible. A total P.O.S. in every way, with large chunks of the cover missing (the entire back cover can be GONE in this grade, or up to 1/4 of the front cover missing).

 

This book is probably a 2.0, maybe a 1.8 on a bad day.

 

Yes, and I received the Grade on the Grail too!

 

"Amazing Fantasy #15 1.8 Off-White Pages - Universal Blue Label"

[FFB]

1.0

 

Davidking623

 

DK,

With all due respect, I believe it qualifies on every point for a GD 2.0. The only borderline detail is the right edge, and how you read the OS guide. Certainly no lower than a 1.8

cheers,

divad

 

Agreed. That book is way better than 1.0. 1.0 is bordering on uncollectible. A total P.O.S. in every way, with large chunks of the cover missing (the entire back cover can be GONE in this grade, or up to 1/4 of the front cover missing).

 

This book is probably a 2.0, maybe a 1.8 on a bad day.

 

Yes, and I received the Grade on the Grail too!

 

"Amazing Fantasy #15 1.8 Off-White Pages - Universal Blue Label"

 

BOOOOOO-YAHHHHHH!!!!

 

Congrats, David! Nice pickup, too!

[marvelcollector]

In my (very) humble opinion - 2.0

congrats!

[Silver Surfer]

2.0.

[Aces]

1.0

 

Davidking623

 

DK,

With all due respect, I believe it qualifies on every point for a GD 2.0. The only borderline detail is the right edge, and how you read the OS guide. Certainly no lower than a 1.8

cheers,

divad

 

Agreed. That book is way better than 1.0. 1.0 is bordering on uncollectible. A total P.O.S. in every way, with large chunks of the cover missing (the entire back cover can be GONE in this grade, or up to 1/4 of the front cover missing).

 

This book is probably a 2.0, maybe a 1.8 on a bad day.

 

Yes, and I received the Grade on the Grail too!

 

"Amazing Fantasy #15 1.8 Off-White Pages - Universal Blue Label"

 

Once again my 1.5 grade fits perfectly into my technique!

[Calamerica]

1.5

 

CAL

[uclapeterg]

1.0

 

Davidking623

 

DK,

With all due respect, I believe it qualifies on every point for a GD 2.0. The only borderline detail is the right edge, and how you read the OS guide. Certainly no lower than a 1.8

cheers,

divad

 

Agree. More with the 1.8 than the 2.0

 

 

I think we should do ok with the grading contest!

[davidking623]

1.0Davidking623

DK,With all due respect, I believe it qualifies on every point for a GD 2.0. The only borderline detail is the right edge, and how you read the OS guide. Certainly no lower than a 1.8 cheers,divad

Click to view supersized image

Click to view supersized image

 

 

Reliable image hosting provided by Vendio. Unlimited images for $12.95.

With the most respect of a gentleman and not hating your book but completely appreciating it fully Divad I must say maybe I jumped the gun but feel after a more further review!1.5Davidking623

Hi Divad!Congrats on the 1.8 I guess my undergrader skills still show along the way! Also congrats on the sale! Davidking623