PGM: All Star Comics 8

[reddwarf666222]

Here is my recent pick up. An All Star Comics 8 with pieces cut out of one page which is an ad one side and a written story on the other side at least it is not any of the comic itself or the Wonder Woman section. I'm guessing a .5, but I have seen other comics with much worse covers get better grades.

[BillS25]

I can speak from experience that CGC will give it a .5

[reddwarf666222]

Looks like you got a nicely loved All Star Comics 8 as well Bill. It just gives the issue character as I look at it.

[MR SigS]

Normally I suggest you shouldn't "contaminate" your PGM thread by stating what you feel the grade is, just so the viewer has no number in their mind as they start looking at your book.

 

But that's not a problem here. I agree with your .5

[Lost]

Wowie. That is the nicest looking .5 I'll ever see. Nice find and great book!

[reddwarf666222]

This is the one instance when I was 99 percent positive of the grade mainly because of the cutouts on the one paper, but I have seen worse covers get better grades than a .5 than the cover I have here so it was a longshot.

[ARK]

Normally I suggest you shouldn't "contaminate" your PGM thread by stating what you feel the grade is, just so the viewer has no number in their mind as they start looking at your book.

 

But that's not a problem here. I agree with your .5

 

+1

[Hibou]

Nice book!

 

 

Was this found at a convention?

 

I could actually see it getting a 1.0...

[mar-vell]

scan down